Spandidos Publications Logo
  • About
    • About Spandidos
    • Aims and Scopes
    • Abstracting and Indexing
    • Editorial Policies
    • Reprints and Permissions
    • Job Opportunities
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Contact
  • Journals
    • All Journals
    • Oncology Letters
      • Oncology Letters
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • International Journal of Oncology
      • International Journal of Oncology
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Molecular and Clinical Oncology
      • Molecular and Clinical Oncology
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine
      • Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • International Journal of Molecular Medicine
      • International Journal of Molecular Medicine
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Biomedical Reports
      • Biomedical Reports
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Oncology Reports
      • Oncology Reports
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Molecular Medicine Reports
      • Molecular Medicine Reports
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • World Academy of Sciences Journal
      • World Academy of Sciences Journal
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • International Journal of Functional Nutrition
      • International Journal of Functional Nutrition
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • International Journal of Epigenetics
      • International Journal of Epigenetics
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Medicine International
      • Medicine International
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
  • Articles
  • Information
    • Information for Authors
    • Information for Reviewers
    • Information for Librarians
    • Information for Advertisers
    • Conferences
  • Language Editing
Spandidos Publications Logo
  • About
    • About Spandidos
    • Aims and Scopes
    • Abstracting and Indexing
    • Editorial Policies
    • Reprints and Permissions
    • Job Opportunities
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Contact
  • Journals
    • All Journals
    • Biomedical Reports
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • International Journal of Epigenetics
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • International Journal of Functional Nutrition
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • International Journal of Molecular Medicine
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • International Journal of Oncology
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Medicine International
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Molecular and Clinical Oncology
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Molecular Medicine Reports
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Oncology Letters
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • Oncology Reports
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
    • World Academy of Sciences Journal
      • Information for Authors
      • Editorial Policies
      • Editorial Board
      • Aims and Scope
      • Abstracting and Indexing
      • Bibliographic Information
      • Archive
  • Articles
  • Information
    • For Authors
    • For Reviewers
    • For Librarians
    • For Advertisers
    • Conferences
  • Language Editing
Login Register Submit
  • This site uses cookies
  • You can change your cookie settings at any time by following the instructions in our Cookie Policy. To find out more, you may read our Privacy Policy.

    I agree
Search articles by DOI, keyword, author or affiliation
Search
Advanced Search
presentation
World Academy of Sciences Journal
Join Editorial Board Propose a Special Issue
Print ISSN: 2632-2900 Online ISSN: 2632-2919
Journal Cover
November-December 2026 Volume 8 Issue 6

Full Size Image

Sign up for eToc alerts
Recommend to Library

Journals

International Journal of Molecular Medicine

International Journal of Molecular Medicine

International Journal of Molecular Medicine is an international journal devoted to molecular mechanisms of human disease.

International Journal of Oncology

International Journal of Oncology

International Journal of Oncology is an international journal devoted to oncology research and cancer treatment.

Molecular Medicine Reports

Molecular Medicine Reports

Covers molecular medicine topics such as pharmacology, pathology, genetics, neuroscience, infectious diseases, molecular cardiology, and molecular surgery.

Oncology Reports

Oncology Reports

Oncology Reports is an international journal devoted to fundamental and applied research in Oncology.

Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine

Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine

Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine is an international journal devoted to laboratory and clinical medicine.

Oncology Letters

Oncology Letters

Oncology Letters is an international journal devoted to Experimental and Clinical Oncology.

Biomedical Reports

Biomedical Reports

Explores a wide range of biological and medical fields, including pharmacology, genetics, microbiology, neuroscience, and molecular cardiology.

Molecular and Clinical Oncology

Molecular and Clinical Oncology

International journal addressing all aspects of oncology research, from tumorigenesis and oncogenes to chemotherapy and metastasis.

World Academy of Sciences Journal

World Academy of Sciences Journal

Multidisciplinary open-access journal spanning biochemistry, genetics, neuroscience, environmental health, and synthetic biology.

International Journal of Functional Nutrition

International Journal of Functional Nutrition

Open-access journal combining biochemistry, pharmacology, immunology, and genetics to advance health through functional nutrition.

International Journal of Epigenetics

International Journal of Epigenetics

Publishes open-access research on using epigenetics to advance understanding and treatment of human disease.

Medicine International

Medicine International

An International Open Access Journal Devoted to General Medicine.

Journal Cover
November-December 2026 Volume 8 Issue 6

Full Size Image

Sign up for eToc alerts
Recommend to Library

  • Article
  • Citations
    • Cite This Article
    • Download Citation
    • Create Citation Alert
    • Remove Citation Alert
    • Cited By
  • Similar Articles
    • Related Articles (in Spandidos Publications)
    • Similar Articles (Google Scholar)
    • Similar Articles (PubMed)
  • Download PDF
  • Download XML
  • View XML

  • Supplementary Files
    • Supplementary_Data.pdf
Article Open Access

Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review

  • Authors:
    • Maryam Hameed Alwan
    • Ban Abdulghani
    • Mohammad Mahmoud Farhan Al-Halbosiy
  • View Affiliations / Copyright

    Affiliations: Department of Oral Diagnostic Science, College of Dentistry, Baghdad University, P.O. Box 1417, Baghdad, Iraq, Biotechnology Research Center, Al-Nahrain University, P.O. Box 64074, Baghdad, Iraq
    Copyright: © Alwan et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of Creative Commons Attribution License [CC BY 4.0].
  • Article Number: 94
    |
    Published online on: September 22, 2026
       https://doi.org/10.3892/wasj.2026.509
  • Expand metrics +
Metrics: Total Views: 0 (Spandidos Publications: | PMC Statistics: )
Metrics: Total PDF Downloads: 0 (Spandidos Publications: | PMC Statistics: )
Cited By (CrossRef): 0 citations Loading Articles...

This article is mentioned in:


Abstract

The present systematic review aimed to combine the evidence on rodent models on molecular regulators of root dentinogenesis across the temporal phases and spatial zones, and evaluate the translation of this map for human dental development and regenerative therapies. A PRISMA 2020‑guided systematic review of experimental studies through the major electronic databases was performed. Data on models, molecules, techniques, spatiotemporal expression and the functional outcomes were extracted. The ARRIVE guidelines and SYRCLE's risk of bias tool were used to assess the risk of bias in animal studies. The evidence form rodent studies supports an organized network that begins with initiation at the cervical loop that requires the downregulation of mesenchymal fibroblast growth factor (FGF)10 and the activation of epithelial Sonic hedgehog (SHH) and mesenchymal bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)2/4. During elongation, the cervical zone exhibits high nuclear factor IC (NFIC), BMP/TGF‑β and dentin sialoprotein (DSPP) activity associated with differentiation, whereas the apical zone maintains proliferation through SHH, FGF2 and Wnt signaling. Maturation involves the upregulation of dentin sialophosphoprotein (DSPP) and dentin matrix protein 1 (DMP1), followed by Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERS) disintegration. The signaling crosstalk indicates that NFIC modulates Hh through Hhip, BMP/TGF‑β inhibits Wnt to prevent ossification and RUNX2 activates the Wnt inhibitor, Notum. The rodent‑derived spatiotemporal framework reveals evidence of conservation for selected molecular pathways in human genetic and cellular studies, while the extent to which the complete spatial and temporal organization is conserved in human root development remains incompletely defined. The synthesis therefore provides a conceptual basis for further mechanistic and preclinical investigation of biomimetic regenerative strategies.

Introduction

Root dentin forms the bulk of the tooth root, providing structural support and anchorage for the tooth within the jawbone. It is vital for tooth function and integrity, and any defects in root dentin formation, arrested root development, short root anomaly and dentin dysplasia can lead to tooth loss. Although critical, root dentinogenesis has received less attention than crown development, even though it is essential for occlusion, periodontal health and sensory function. The understanding of root development at the molecular level is crucial for the diagnosis of congenital root defects and for designing regenerative endodontic therapies (1).

Anatomically, once crown formation is complete, a new epithelial structure, the Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERS), appears. HERS is formed from the fusion of inner and outer enamel epithelia at the cervical loop and extends apically. It functions as a temporary scaffold and its signals induce the underlying neural crest-derived mesenchyme (dental papilla) to condense and differentiate into pre-odontoblasts and odontoblasts that deposit root dentin; HERS then disintegrates to permit cementum and ligament formation. When HERS continuity is disrupted experimentally, odontoblast differentiation fails and roots are malformed (1).

Furthermore, HERS itself secretes signaling and growth factors that function as a local signaling center to orchestrate root formation (2,3). Simultaneously, the apical papilla [the undifferentiated mesenchyme at the root tip that contains the stem cells of the apical papilla (SCAPs)] also contributes progenitor cells for dentinogenesis. Therefore, root development depends on coordinated epithelial-mesenchymal interactions involving HERS and apical stem cells (1,2). Different regions along the root axis (cervical, middle and apical thirds) and different developmental stages (initiation, elongation and maturation) feature distinct signaling environments (4,5). The molecular gradient along the tooth root is increasingly recognized, and certain growth and transcription factors are upregulated in early HERS growth, but are subsequently downregulated thereafter, while others peak in mid-root. For instance, Wnt10a exhibits a dynamic epithelial and mesenchymal expression pattern during tooth-root development, with stage-dependent changes associated with root furcation morphogenesis (4), and bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) and Sonic hedgehog (SHH) are present at the onset of root formation in the inner enamel epithelium and dental mesenchyme (5). Therefore, it was hypothesized that dynamic spatial and temporal patterns of signaling molecules, rather than a uniform environment, regulates root patterning.

Animal models, particularly mouse molars, provide key experimental systems for investigating the cellular and molecular mechanisms of tooth-root development, including the spatiotemporal regulation of HERS, dental mesenchymal progenitors and odontoblast differentiation (1). The findings from these models provide a basis for investigating the relevance of selected developmental pathways to human root development and regeneration.

The present systematic review aimed to integrate all available evidence from rodent models on the molecular regulation of root dentinogenesis, organized along both temporal and spatial axes. Moreover, a detailed spatiotemporal map of signaling pathways [e.g., nuclear factor IC (NFIC)/TGF-β, BMP/Smad, Wnt/β-catenin, SHH, fibroblast growth factor (FGF) and dentin sialoprotein (DSPP)] during root formation was constructed, and the extent to which this rodent-based map can be translated to human dental development and applied in dental regeneration was evaluated.

Data and methods

The PRISMA 2020 guidelines for systematic reviews were followed. A comprehensive full literature search was performed using the PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science databases from database inception to December, 2025. The database search used three predefined concept blocks: i) Root development and related anatomical/developmental terms; ii) molecular, gene-expression, signaling pathway, transcription factor and growth factor terms; and iii) rodent species terms. The Boolean structure was [(‘root development’ OR ‘root formation’ OR ‘root dentinogenesis’ OR ‘Hertwig’s epithelial root sheath’ OR ‘odontoblast differentiation’ OR ‘apical papilla development’) AND (molecular OR ‘gene expression’ OR ‘signaling pathway’ OR BMP OR Wnt OR FGF OR SHH OR NFIC OR RUNX2 OR DSPP OR DMP1 OR ‘transcription factor’ OR ‘growth factor’) AND (rat OR mouse OR rodent OR murine)].

Inclusion criteria

Eligibility was defined using the Population, Exposure, Comparator, and Outcome (PECO) criteria. The population comprised developing root tissues of permanent teeth, including HERS, dental papilla/apical papilla and odontoblasts. The exposure comprised experimentally investigated molecules or signaling pathways, including gene expression studies, genetic manipulation and pathway inhibition. Comparators included different developmental time points or spatial regions and, where available, wild-type vs. mutant or experimentally manipulated conditions. Outcomes included root dentin histology, molecular expression patterns and dentin measurements or histomorphometric findings. Only original experimental studies providing interpretable spatial or temporal information and a molecular mechanism relevant to root development were eligible.

Exclusion criteria

Studies limited to crown development, primary teeth, non-mammalian species, in vitro systems without an eligible in vivo root development component, reviews, editorials, conference abstracts and studies lacking interpretable spatial/temporal or mechanistic information were excluded.

Study selection

The identified records were imported into Rayyan software (https://new.rayyan.ai/reviews). Duplications were removed automatically and verified manually. Moreover, two reviewers MHA and BAG, independently checked titles and abstracts for relevance, then reviewed full texts of potentially qualified articles.

The data were extracted into a table and the extracted items included the following: Author, year of publication; species and model, the key molecule/pathway, the experimental technique and the spatiotemporal expression pattern with the functional role/outcome and any reported human correlation.

The results were then organized into spatial zones and temporal phases. The spatial zones covered the regions involved in root elongation and maturation; cervical (near the enamel junction), middle and apical (root tip) thirds of the root were considered. Furthermore, the temporal phases were initiation (root patterning and onset of HERS), elongation (active odontoblast differentiation and dentin deposition) and maturation (dentin mineralization and root apex closure).

Assessment of reporting quality and risk of bias

Reporting quality was assessed using an adaptation of the ARRIVE 2.0 Essential 10 framework and, as the ARRIVE 2.0 guidelines do not prescribe a numerical scoring system, a descriptive scoring approach was applied to the 10 Essential 10 items: 1 point for fully reported, 0.5 points for partially reported, and 0 points for not reported. This scoring approach was based on a previously published ARRIVE reporting-quality assessment that used the same 1/0.5/0 scoring system to distinguish fully reported, partially reported and unreported information (6,7). In the present systematic review, the score was restricted to the 10 ARRIVE Essential 10 items, and the total score was expressed as a percentage of the maximum possible score.

Risk of bias was assessed using the Systematic Review Centre for Laboratory animal Experimentation (SYRCLE) tool for animal studies (8). The risk-of-bias tool is comprised of 10 items as follows: D1, sequence generation; D2, baseline characteristics; D3, allocation concealment; D4, random housing; D5, blinding of investigators; D6, random outcome assessment; D7, blinding of outcome assessment; D8, incomplete outcome data; D9, selective outcome reporting; D10, other sources of bias. For each item, the judgment was ‘low’, ‘high’, or ‘unclear’ risk of bias.

Results

Study selection

The database search identified 1,922 records (PubMed, 398; Scopus, 431; Web of Science, 1,093). Following the removal of 150 duplicates and 806 records for other reasons (non-English and reviews), 966 records remained for title/abstract screening. Of these, 687 were excluded and 279 full-text articles were assessed for eligibility. A total of 215 full-text articles were excluded for the following reasons: In vitro only (n=12), data limited to crown (n=2), missing spatial/temporal data (n=141), missing molecular mechanism (descriptive only) (n=32), reviews (n=5), not related to root development (n=17), non-rodent (n=6). Finally, 64 studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in the qualitative synthesis, as illustrated in the PRISMA flow diagram (Fig. 1).

PRISMA 2020 flow diagram outlining
the systematic search and selection process, yielding 64 eligible
studies from 1,922 initial records.

Figure 1

PRISMA 2020 flow diagram outlining the systematic search and selection process, yielding 64 eligible studies from 1,922 initial records.

Study characteristics

A total of 64 studies (3-5,9-69) met the inclusion criteria and were included in the qualitative synthesis. The evidence was predominantly derived from in vivo mouse studies (n=61), with three studies using rats. Common experimental approaches included genetic knockout or conditional deletion models and pathway-specific manipulation. The reported techniques included immunohistochemistry, in situ hybridization, micro-CT and RNA-based analyses. In total, 18 studies also reported human correlative evidence, including human genetic findings, histological observations, or experiments using human stem cells from the apical papilla. Detailed characteristics of all the included studies, including model, developmental phase, spatial comparison and principal findings, are presented in Table I. Molecular interactions and functional validation are summarized in Table SI, while rodent findings and reported human evidence are summarized in Tables II and SII.

Table I

The 64 studies that met the inclusion criteria.

Table I

The 64 studies that met the inclusion criteria.

First author, year of publicationModelTemporal phaseSpatial zones comparedKey spatial finding(Refs.)
Steele-Perkins, 2003NFIC KO MouseInitiationLabial, lingualNFIC-/- molars have normal crowns but completely lack roots. Incisors show asymmetric dentin formation (labial normal, lingual absent). Alveolar bone fails to form specifically around missing roots.(9)
Shimamura, 2025Chd3 KO mouseInitiationCervical width vs. Crown width; Apical papilla vs. other dental papillaCervical width significantly narrowed at PN8; Ki-67+ cells decreased specifically in apical papilla at PN8.(10)
Yokohama-Tamaki, 2006Mouse incisor (Fgf10-/- transplant), mouse molar cultureInitiationLabial vs. lingual side; IEE vs. OEE/stellate reticulum; crown analog vs. root analogLoss of Fgf10 causes labial side (normally crown-forming) to develop root-like structures with HERS and fragmented epithelium, mimicking molar root development.(11)
Sun, 2024K14-Cre; Wnt10a mouse (M1)InitiationHERS in presumptive root furcation region (buccal vs. lingual, elongation direction)Wnt10a ablation impairs horizontal elongation of HERS; increases angle of elongation vs. horizontal plane.(12)
Fujiwara, 2009Mouse ddY, lower first molarInitiationCervical loop (IEE, OEE, SR) vs. HERS; Crown vs. root apexReduction of Egf signaling in the cervical loop is necessary for SR disappearance and subsequent HERS formation, initiating root development.(13)
Yu, 2020K14-Cre; Wnt10a fl/fl mouse molars Initiation/elongationCervical loop/furcation region epithelium vs. mesenchyme; furcation vs. non-furcation (mesial) regionLoss of epi-Wnt10a decreases epithelial proliferation in presumptive furcation at PN0 but increases mesenchymal proliferation in the furcation at PN4/7, leading to failed furcation formation.(4)
Hirose, 2013C57BL/6 mouse, PN10-20 Initiation/elongationHERS basal vs. apical tipAMBN localized in basal HERS, absent at tip; siRNA causes multilayered basal HERS(17)
Ihn, 2021Bbx KO mouse Initiation/elongationCrown vs. root; mesial vs. distal root; dental epithelium vs. mesenchyme; odontoblasts vs. HERS cellsBbx expressed in both epithelium and mesenchyme during development. KO leads to shorter mesial and distal roots but normal crown length.(18)
Hosoya, 2008Mouse (ICR) first molar Initiation/elongationHERS vs. surrounding dental papilla/mesenchyme vs. odontoblast layerBMP4 is expressed in mesenchyme surrounding HERS; BMP receptors localized in HERS cells. BMP4 from mesenchyme signals to HERS to inhibit its elongation.(19)
Huang, 2019BMP9-KO mouse Initiation/elongationWhole-root comparison (KO vs. WT): Root length, mid-root dentin thickness, apical foramen width; no explicit cervical vs. apical comparison within rootsBMP9 deficiency leads to globally shorter roots, thinner dentin, and wider apical foramen.(20)
Gama, 2020Mouse (C57BL/6J), Rankl-/-,+/-, Tg; Anti-RANKL Ab Initiation/elongationLingual vs. buccal; HERS vs. dental pulp vs. apical follicle vs. alveolar boneBone matrix deposition preferentially interrupts follicle-papilla boundary in buccal region in Rankl-/-. HERS cell number differs between lingual/buccal regions and genotypes.(21)
Nagata, 2025Mouse (C57BL/6); Cxcl12-creER lineage tracing; Ctnnb1 cKO Initiation/elongationAP vs. coronal dental papilla; root dentin (inside) vs. cementum (outside)CXCL12+ cells emerge specifically in the hypoxic AP at root onset (P3). These progenitors give rise to odontoblasts (inner dentin) and cementoblasts (outer root surface).(22)
Mu, 2021K14-cre; Bmp2/4 dKO mouse Initiation/elongationHERS (epithelium) vs. root mesenchyme (odontoblasts/dental papilla)Epithelial Bmp2/4 deficiency disrupts signaling in adjacent mesenchyme, suppressing odontoblast differentiation and dentin formation.(23)
Liu, 2023Mouse (Fam20a epi-cKO) Initiation/elongationHERS; cervical vs. apical periodontium; coronal eruption pathHERS is disorganized and persists longer in cKO; cervical and apical periodontal fiber orientation is altered in cKO at P16.(24)
Bae, 2013Mouse WT & β-catenin cKO Initiation/elongationCrown odontoblasts vs. apical odontoblasts (root apex)Identifies ‘apical odontoblasts’ (AOds) as a distinct population located at the apical side of developing roots, responsible for root formation.(25)
Kim, 2015Nfic KO mouse Initiation/elongationElongation region vs. furcation regionIn mutants, cell proliferation decreased in elongation region but increased in furcation region; leads to short roots and abnormal/delayed furcation (taurodontism-like).(26)
Romero, 2017Eda/Edar mutant mice Initiation/elongationBifurcation region vs. outside; buccal vs. lingual HERS; mesenchymal zones adjacent to HERSMutant HERS extends at a wider, more vertical angle in the bifurcation region; increased mesenchymal proliferation adjacent to HERS in non-bifurcating mutants.(27)
Chen, 2014SD rat, WT Initiation/elongationHERS cells vs. adjacent DPCs vs. distant DPCs/DFCsNfic expression is highest in DPCs immediately adjacent to HERS; absent in HERS itself.(28)
Ma, 2021Mouse mesenchymal Ror2 conditional knockout (Osr2-Cre) Initiation/elongationApical dental mesenchyme vs. epithelium; crown vs. root; furcation vs. elongation region; odontoblast differentiation in apical regionRor2 in dental mesenchyme regulates cell proliferation specifically in the apical region, affecting root elongation and furcation formation. Crown development is unaffected.(14)
Wen, 2020Mouse mandibular first molar; Gli1-CreERT2;Runx2 <sup>fl/fl</sup> conditional KO Initiation/elongationApical dental mesenchyme vs. other regions; HERS vs. adjacent dental papilla; preodontoblast regionRUNX2+ cells are a subpopulation of GLI1+ MSCs in the apical mesenchyme. NOTUM expression is restricted to preodontoblasts adjacent to HERS. Runx2 ablation disrupts cellular patterning and differentiation in this specific zone.(29)
Pei, 2024Mouse (Gli1-CreER; Fgfr2fl/fl) Initiation/elongation Apical/middle/coronal papilla; dental follicle; HERS; odontoblast layer; PDLSensory nerves and FGF1 enriched in apical papilla. Fgfr2 expressed in Gli1+ progenitors in papilla/follicle. Loss of Fgfr2 disrupts proliferation/differentiation in these zones.(15)
Huang, 2010K14-Cre; Smad4fl/fl and Nfic-/- mouse molars Initiation/elongationCrown vs. root; HERS (epithelium) vs. dental papilla/follicle (mesenchyme)Without Smad4, HERS enlarges at the crown apex but fails to elongate apically to guide root formation.(3)
Lav, 2023Mouse Gli1creERT2; Wls cKO Initiation/elongationApex vs. crown base; apical HERS vs. mesenchyme; radicular vs. periodontal tissuesWnt-responsive Axin2+ stem/progenitors shift from crown base to root apex during development. Loss of apical Wnts disrupts HERS integrity and apical mesenchymal organization.(30)
Kim, 2013Mouse β-catenin cKO (odontoblast) Initiation/elongationCrown vs. cervix vs. apical region; HERS inner vs. outer layer; odontoblast lineage stagesβ-catenin loss disrupts odontoblast differentiation specifically in the cervical region, preventing root dentin formation despite HERS extension.(31)
Lohi, 2010Axin2-lacZ mouse Initiation/elongationCervical (cusp/ameloblast-free zone) vs. apical (root); Epithelium (enamel knots) vs. mesenchyme (papilla); crown vs. rootCanonical Wnt activity (via Axin2) is excluded from ameloblasts, high in enamel-free cusp tips and root-forming regions (HERS, dental papilla, inter-radicular zone).(32)
Liu, 2015Mouse 1st mandibular molar (WT & Nfic-/-) Initiation/elongationHERS vs. Apical Papilla; Gradient within AP (proximal vs. distal to HERS)Shh ligand expressed in HERS. Hh activity (Gli1) highest in HERS, forms a diminishing gradient into the AP. Proliferation highest in AP cells nearest HERS.(5)
Liu, 2026Mouse Bmp9-KO and adenovirus silencing Initiation/elongation/maturationApical foramen width, root dentin thickness, HERS, odontoblast layerBmp9 deficiency leads to shorter roots, wider apical foramen, thinner dentin, impaired odontoblast differentiation, and reduced HERS proliferation.(33)
Li, 2023Sox2-Cre; Fam20c cKO mouse Initiation/elongation/maturationCrown vs. root region; focus on root odontoblasts and apical papillaDefects (morphological, differentiation, proliferation) were more severe in the root region compared to the crown in cKO mice.(34)
Xu, 2016MT1-MMP KO (mouse) Initiation/elongation/maturationCervical vs. apical root; buccal vs. lingual aspects; HERS vs. papilla/follicle; PDL vs. bone interfaceHERS structure altered apically; Dentin thinner in roots; PDL disorganized with absent Sharpey's fiber insertion into bone; reduced alveolar bone formation.(35)
Du, 2021Mouse Gli1-CreER; Arid1afl/fl Initiation/elongation/maturationApical progenitor region vs. differentiated root regions (furcation, lateral)Loss of Arid1a in apical Gli1+ progenitors leads to overactivated proliferation in apical region but impaired differentiation into odontoblasts and PDL throughout root.(36)
Park, 2007Nfic KO mouse Initiation/elongation/maturationCervical root vs. apical root; HERS vs. odontoblast layerNfic disruption does not affect HERS morphology but causes disorganized, non-polarized odontoblasts specifically in the root, leading to short, abnormal roots resembling osteodentin.(37)
Ono, 2016Mouse genetic models (PPR cKO) Initiation/elongation/maturationDental follicle vs. papilla; cervical (CEJ) to apex; root surface (cementum/PDL) vs. dentin/pulp; interradicular areaOss+ progenitors in dental follicle/papilla give rise to all root lineages. PPR signaling in these cells is essential for proliferation at HERS and formation of organized PDL/acellular cementum. PTHrP is expressed on the root surface in cementoblasts/PDL cells.(38)
Yun, 2016Mouse (Osr2-Cre; Smad4fl/fl, OC-Cre; Smad4fl/fl) Initiation/elongation/maturationCrown dentin vs. root dentin (particularly cervical region)Smad4 loss leads to thinner crown dentin and replacement of root/cervical dentin with ectopic bone-like tissue.(39)
Zhang, 2013Mouse OC-Cre; Ctnnb1 cKO Initiation/elongation/maturationCrown vs. root; cervical vs. apical root; labial vs. lingual incisor; HERS vs. papillaWnt/β-catenin signaling is active in apical pre-odontoblasts and HERS. Its loss disrupts root/lingual dentin and periodontium formation, but crown/labial structures remain intact.(40)
Lapthanasupkul, 2012Mouse; Ring1a-/-; Ring1bcko/cko (conditional KO)ElongationCervical vs. apical (molar root); HERS vs. dental papilla (Bmp4 expression).Expression of Ring1a, Ring1b, Nspc1, Fbxl10 and Skp1 were all found to be localized in postnatal molars in apical areas at the early stages of root formation, particularly in root odontoblasts.(41)
Zheng, 2024Mouse (K14-Cre; Axin1 cKO)ElongationHERS vs. apical mesenchymeAxin1 expression and function is restricted to HERS epithelium; its loss disrupts signaling to adjacent odontoblasts.(16)
Huang, 2018RANKL KO mouseElongationHERS vs. dental pulp; radicular odontoblast region (whole root)HERS elongation and radicular odontoblast differentiation are disrupted in the mutant.(42)
Wang, 2023Atp6i KO mouseElongationHERS vs. dental papilla; odontoblast layerHERS truncation in mutants; p-Smad2/3 attenuation in odontoblast layer.(43)
Cui, 2024Mouse incisor/molar; human DPSCsElongationLingual (root) vs. labial (crown); cervical loop, papilla-pulp, dental follicle; apical/coronal/middle papillaHMCN1 expression is higher on the root-forming (lingual) side in cervical loop and pulp-papilla, and is concentrated in the root-side dental pulp and odontoblasts.(44)
Zhang, 2015Mouse odontoblast-specific Ctnnb1 conditional knockoutElongationHERS structure along the developing root (cervical to apical progression)Loss of β-catenin in odontoblasts leads to premature and excessive HERS fenestration/fragmentation, disrupting normal root elongation.(45)
Sheng, 2021Mouse (C57BL6/J) conditional KO; human DPCsElongationCrown vs. rootMETTL3 expression differs between crown and root. METTL3 loss causes root-specific defects: short/thin root, sparse odontoblast processes in radicular but not coronal dentin.(46)
Bae, 2013Mouse [OC-Cre: Catnb+/lox(ex3)]ElongationCervical region (300 and 100 µm apical to CEJ)Mutants have thin, hypomineralized root dentin and excessive cementum deposition along the root surface compared to WT.(47)
Lee, 2009Nfic KO mouseElongationIncisor: Labial crown analog vs. lingual root analog; odontoblast layer organizationNfic deficiency causes dentin formation failure in the lingual root analog and abnormal dentin/odontoblast dissociation in the labial analog. Loss of odontoblast polarity and sheet-like arrangement.(48)
Khan, 2007Mouse (CD-1) wild-typeElongationCervical margin vs. early root dentine vs. apical HERS; HERS epithelium vs. adjacent papilla/follicle mesenchyme vs. peripheral mesenchymeSHH signaling is active only in HERS epithelium and adjacent mesenchyme within a short range (few cell diameters). Differentiated root odontoblasts show no SHH pathway activity.(49)
Nakatomi, 2006Mouse Ptc<sup>mes</sup> mutantElongationHERS vs. adjacent dental mesenchyme (pulp proliferation zone); epithelium vs. mesenchyme; apical vs. coronal regionsShh signaling molecule expression and cell proliferation markers extensively overlap in the mesenchyme adjacent to HERS. Loss of Shh signaling represses proliferation in this zone.(50)
Yang, 2021Inducible β-catenin CKO/stabilization in mouse HERSElongationHERS bilayer vs. dental papilla; Root apexβ-catenin loss disrupts HERS bilayer integrity prematurely; β-catenin stabilization prevents HERS dissociation. Altered signaling from HERS affects adjacent papilla cells.(51)
Hosoya, 2025Lewis rat (wild-type and injury) Elongation/maturationApical vs. coronal root odontoblasts; cervical loop vs. differentiated zone in incisorBmi1, nuclear β-catenin and p-Smad1/5/8 show strong apical-to-weak coronal gradient in root odontoblasts.(52)
Wang, 2021Mouse M1 (BRE-LacZ, BAT-gal) Elongation/maturationDental sac, crown pulp vs. root pulp, apical papilla, HERS, mesenchyme below cuspsBMP activity shifts coronally to apically; Wnt activity initiates under cusps, expands around root, then disappears.(53)
Rakian, 2013Bmp2-cKO (Sp7-Cre) mouse Elongation/maturationCervical loop vs. apical papilla; pulp vs. odontoblast layer vs. periodontium; CIFC vs. AEFCBmp2 deletion in Sp7+ cells disrupts terminal differentiation in root odontoblasts and organization of the periodontium and cementum.(54)
Bae, 2015Mouse odontoblast-specific Wls CKO Elongation/maturationCrown vs. root; cervical vs. apical; odontoblast layer; HERSDentin thickness reduced more severely in roots; Root elongation impaired due to reduced cell proliferation at apex; HERS fragmentation delayed.(55)
Li, 2018Mouse Ift140 cKO Elongation/maturationFuture cusp vs. root area; Furcation/Interradicular dentin; root vs. crown dentinIFT140 expressed in root odontoblasts; Deletion causes thin interradicular dentin, short roots, but normal crown dentin.(56)
Sun, 2010CaR KO and double KO mice Elongation/maturationApical pulp, Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERs), predentin vs. mineralized dentin, dental alveolar boneIn CaR-/- mice: PTHrP+ and PCNA+ cells decreased in apical pulp and HERs; predentin area increased; mineralized dentin and alveolar bone volume decreased. Rescued in CaR-/-; Pth-/- mice.(57)
Nakatomi, 2013Rat incisor and molar (developmental + injury) Elongation/maturationIncisor (apical bud to mature zone) vs. molar (crown vs. root dentin formation); Intact vs. injured pulpLef1 expression precedes Dspp in all spatial contexts. Markers are downregulated in resting molar odontoblasts but not in continuously growing incisors.(58)
Gao, 2014Mouse (P1-P20), human SCAPs in vitro and in vivo transplant Elongation/maturation Odontoblasts/preodontoblasts vs. pulp vs. apical papilla vs. PDL vs. alveolar bone vs. HERS; coronal vs. root pulpNFIC expression strongest in odontoblasts/preodontoblasts, weak in pulp/apical papilla, absent in HERS. Higher in coronal vs. root pulp.(59)
Zhang, 2015Osx cKO and Nfic KO mice Elongation/maturationCrown dentin vs. root dentin; Incisor crown-analog vs. root-analogOSX is essential for establishing normal dentin tubule architecture and thickness in the root, but not in the crown.(60)
Kim, 2015Mouse conditional Osx KO (Col1a1-Cre; OC-Cre) Elongation/maturationi) Crown vs. root; ii) root apex (elongation) vs. interradicular (furcation) dentinOsx is required in root, but not crown odontoblasts. Root shortening and severe interradicular dentin hypoplasia.(61)
Wang, 2017Bmp1/Tll1 conditional dKO mouse Elongation/maturationCrown vs. root; central vs. lateral rootRoot defects more severe than crown. Predentin expansion greater in lateral vs. central root.(62)
Foster, 2013Alpl-/- mouse Elongation/maturationCrown vs. root; buccal vs. lingual root dentinRoot dentin mineralization defective (esp. lingual aspect); crown dentin spared.(63)
Lin, 2023Mouse (Ogn KO) Elongation/maturationCervical (CEJ) vs. middle vs. apical; apical papilla vs. dental follicleRoot hard tissue (dentin/cementum) thicker at all zones in Ogn-/- mice; Hh pathway activity spatially localized to AP/DF at PN15.(64)
Foster, 2018Spp1-/-, Ank-/- mice Elongation/maturationDentin/cementum, alveolar bone (buccal/lingual, cervical/mid/apical), pulp, PDLSpp1-/- increases dentin/alveolar bone volume/density, decreases pulp/PDL volume. Acellular cementum thickness unchanged.(65)
Jeong, 2024Mouse (inducible β-catenin stabilization in HERS; Catnb <sup>lA5hh</sup>) Elongation/maturationCervical vs. apical (HERS dissociation front)Stabilization of β-catenin in HERS prevents its apical dissociation into epithelial rests of Malassez (ERM), leading to arrested root elongation and hypomineralized apical dentin.(66)
Niibe, 2025Hdac3-CKOosx mice (C57BL/6)MaturationCrown vs. root; mesial vs. distal roots; root apex; cervical loop; dentin/cementum thickness gradientsCKO mice have shorter roots, smaller apices; cementum grows inward closing apex; dentin/cementum structure disorganized and thinner.(67)
Kim, 2015Smad4 cKO mice (Dspp, OC, Col1a1-Cre)MaturationCrown, cervical region, root furcationDentin defects vary by zone; cervical region highly responsive to Smad4 during secondary dentin formation.(68)
Zhang, 2019Mouse (P14), human SCAPsMaturationHERS vs. surrounding mesenchymeGNAI3 expressed in HERS and surrounding mesenchyme during root development.(69)

Table II

Translational validation from rodent phenotypes to humans.

Table II

Translational validation from rodent phenotypes to humans.

Molecule/pathwayCategorySourceTarget cellsFunction in rodent root formationHuman relevance/notes(Refs.)
TGF-β (incl. Smad4)/BMPsInitiatorHERS epithelium/basal laminaDental papilla (odontoblast precursors)Induces odontoblast differentiation and matrix secretion; patterns differentiation along the root axisSmad4 disruption → short roots in rodents; candidate in human root dysplasia(3,19,23,54,68,71,75)
SHH (Sonic hedgehog)Spatial organizerHERS/apical epitheliumSurrounding mesenchyme (Ptch/Gli-expressing cells)Controls proliferation at root apex and contributes to root length and patterning; gradient-dependent effects on root number/shapeImplicated in furcation patterning models(3,5,49,50)
FGF10InitiationApical mesenchyme (cervical loop-associated)HERS and mesenchymeHigh FGF10 maintains crown program; downregulation required to permit root initiation; exogenous FGF10 delays root formationLikely relevant in humans for crown-root transition timing(11)
Wnt/β-catenin (Wnt10a etc.)Growth and differentiationEpithelium and mesenchymeOdontoblasts, HERSPromotes odontoblast differentiation and Dspp expression; influences root length and furcation; Wnt dysregulation → taurodont-like phenotypesWNT10A variants associated with human dental anomalies (e.g., taurodontism)(4,29,30,31,47,51,55)
NFIC (nuclear factor IC)Mesenchymal master regulatorDental papilla (odontoblast lineage)Odontoblast differentiationEssential for root dentinogenesis; knockout → normal crowns but severely defective/short roots (fails to produce proper dentin)Human NFIC perturbation linked to radicular dentin defects; strong translational candidate(3,5,9,48,59)
DSPP (dentin sialophosphoprotein) Matrix/effectorOdontoblasts (secreted)Dentin matrix formation; ECM signalingMajor structural and regulatory dentin matrix protein. Its cleavage products modulate mineralization and cell behaviorDSPP mutations cause dentinogenesis imperfecta in humans(58,60,61,62)
Runx2/Osx (Sp7)Periodontal lineage regulatorsDental follicle/mesenchymeCementoblasts, PDL fibroblasts, alveolar osteoblastsDirect osteo/cementogenic differentiation of follicle cells; loss → short roots and defective PDLRunx2 mutations → bone/tooth phenotypes(29,37,38,60,61)
Wnt antagonists (DKK1, SFRP, Notum)ModulatorsEpithelium and mesenchymeWnt-responsive cells (HERS, follicle)Establish spatiotemporal Wnt gradients necessary for correct root timing and patterningFine-tune furcation and root width(29,47)
Notch, Hippo-YAP, PI3K/AKTEmerging regulatorsEpithelium and mesenchymeProliferation, cell fate, survivalModulate progenitor activity, epithelial-mesenchymal transitions, and cytoskeletal/growth responses during root formation; data still emerging in ratCandidate pathways for translating complex human phenotypes and regeneration(12,16,42)
Spatial and temporal patterning of root development. The initiation phase of root development

Root initiation was characterized by a transition from the crown-forming program to the root-forming program at the cervical loop. The reviewed experimental evidence consistently implicated cessation of FGF10 signaling together with epithelial BMP/SMAD4 and SHH activity in this transition. BMP/SMAD4 signaling was linked to SHH induction, which subsequently contributed to mesenchymal NFIC activation and odontoblast-lineage specification. These findings identify coordinated epithelial-mesenchymal signaling as a central feature of root initiation (3,9-11).

The elongation phase of root development. During root elongation, the evidence supported a spatially organized signaling environment along the apical-cervical axis. The apical region was characterized by signaling associated with progenitor maintenance and proliferation, including SHH/Gli1, Wnt/β-catenin and FGF pathways, whereas the cervical-to-midroot region exhibited greater involvement of BMP/TGF-β signaling and NFIC-dependent odontoblast differentiation (5,12,13). The experimental disruption of these pathways produced region-specific abnormalities, including impaired proliferation, shortened roots, defective odontoblast differentiation and abnormal dentin formation (14-16). The individual experimental models and spatial comparisons are summarized in Table I.

The functional maturation and termination of root development. Root maturation involved continued odontoblast differentiation, dentin matrix production, mineralization and the remodeling of HERS. Sustained NFIC activity and expression of dentin-associated matrix genes, including DSPP and DMP1, were associated with functional dentin maturation (25,53,61,63). The evidence also indicated that HERS remodeling is an active developmental process, with inappropriate persistence or premature disruption of epithelial signaling associated with abnormal root development (30,51). These findings support HERS remodeling as an integral component of root maturation rather than a passive terminal event.

Integrated signaling associations. Across the included studies, multiple pathways exhibited evidence of interaction rather than independent activity. The principal associations identified included BMP/SMAD4-SHH-NFIC signaling (3,23), Wnt/β-catenin regulation by RUNX2-NOTUM (29), epithelial WNT10A interactions with mesenchymal Wnt signaling (4,12), and reciprocal epithelial-mesenchymal regulation involving BMP/TGF-β and HERS (19,23). Detailed interaction evidence and functional validation are provided in Table SI.

Translational relevance of the rodent evidence

The available human evidence supports the biological conservation of selected pathways identified in rodent models; however, it does not establish direct equivalence between rodent and human root development. Human genetic findings, concordant dental phenotypes and experimental observations in human dental stem-cell systems provide evidence that selected regulatory mechanisms are conserved. However, the complete spatial and temporal organization of these pathways during human root development remains incompletely defined.

However, the findings revealed that WNT10A mutations are associated with taurodontism in humans, while Wnt10a deficiency in mice disrupts root furcation morphogenesis through altered epithelial-mesenchymal signaling during root development (4). Additionally, other genes included in the present synthesis, including RUNX2, FAM20A, PTH1R, ROR2, AXIN2 and IFT140, have reported human or rodent associations with dental or craniofacial phenotypes (14,24,29,32,38,56).

Accordingly, the present rodent-based framework should be regarded as a translationally informative model for hypothesis generation and preclinical research rather than as a direct representation of human root development. The translational validation of rodent phenotypes and their relevance to human root-development pathways is summarized in Tables II and SII.

Functional conservation in human dental stem cells

Human stem-cell studies provide additional evidence that selected regulatory mechanisms identified in rodent models are conserved in human dental cells. Human SCAPs express NFIC, respond to FGF2 and TGF-β1 and activate the same NFIC-TGF-β1 feedback loop identified in vivo (43,59). Moreover, the RUNX2-NOTUM axis operates in human cells, confirming the conservation of Wnt attenuation mechanisms (29). These findings support the biological relevance of selected pathways identified in rodent root-development studies. However, the cellular conservation of individual signaling mechanisms does not demonstrate that the complete spatial and temporal signaling network identified in rodent models is reproduced during human root development. Further human developmental and translational studies are therefore required.

Preclinical models for interventions

Several experimental studies have provided preclinical proof-of-concept that selected molecular pathways can be modified to influence root-associated phenotypes (29,63,70,71). Enzyme replacement with a mineral-targeting tissue-nonspecific alkaline phosphatase prevented dental hypomineralization and defects in dentin and cementum in Akp2-/- mice, providing preclinical proof-of-concept for enzyme replacement therapy in hypophosphatasia (63,70). Moreover, pathway modulation is similarly effective: NOTUM protein partially rescues RUNX2 deficiency (29), the inhibition of Wnt signaling attenuates the ectopic osteogenic differentiation associated with Tgfbr2 deletion in root pre-odontoblasts, supporting functional cooperation between TGF-β and Wnt signaling during root odontoblast differentiation (71), and FGF signaling contributes to progenitor cell regulation during tooth root development (15), while NFIC is involved in the odontogenic differentiation of human stem cells from the apical papilla (59). Finally, emerging targets for intervention include CXCL12+ apical progenitors (22), the OGN-Hedgehog axis (64) and HMCN1-mediated extracellular matrix signaling (44).

Quality assessment of selected studies

According to an adaptation of the ARRIVE 2.0 guidelines, the quality scoring system was applied to included studies (Y=1, P=0.5, N/NA=0). Overall, the quality percentages ranged from 30 to 75%, and the majority of studies were within the average-quality range (~50-75%). However, 14 studies scored <50%, reflecting substantial methodological or reporting deficiencies. As detailed in the study-level heatmap (Fig. 2) and summarized by the average compliance per criterion (Fig. 3), outcome reporting, the description of experimental procedures, presentation of results and the reporting of experimental animals were commonly rated as fully or partially adequate. This indicates that the majority of studies clearly describe what was measured, how experiments were conducted and what was observed. On the other hand, items of study design, sample size reporting and statistical analysis were partially addressed. The partial scoring suggests that methods were often mentioned, but lacked justification, transparency or sufficient detail (e.g., absence of power calculations or incomplete statistical descriptions). However, the items that were not reported (inclusion/exclusion criteria, randomization and blinding) directly increased the risk of bias, performance and detection bias.

Heatmap of ARRIVE 2.0 reporting
quality for the 64 included studies (Y=1, P=0.5, N/NA=0). The
overall compliance ranged from 30 to 75%, with the majority of
studies within the average range.

Figure 2

Heatmap of ARRIVE 2.0 reporting quality for the 64 included studies (Y=1, P=0.5, N/NA=0). The overall compliance ranged from 30 to 75%, with the majority of studies within the average range.

Mean ARRIVE 2.0 compliance per
criterion. Outcomes and results were highly reported (>99%),
while randomization, blinding and inclusion/exclusion criteria
exhibited minimal reporting (<5%).

Figure 3

Mean ARRIVE 2.0 compliance per criterion. Outcomes and results were highly reported (>99%), while randomization, blinding and inclusion/exclusion criteria exhibited minimal reporting (<5%).

Risk of bias in studies

Based on the SYRCLE risk of bias assessment, the overall pattern of the included studies indicated a low to unclear risk of bias, with relatively few items consistently reported as high risk. In particular, baseline characteristics (D2), incomplete outcome data (D8), selective outcome reporting (D9) and (D10) any other potential sources of bias, were rated as low risk, suggesting that outcome evaluation and reporting were generally handled in a transparent and reliable manner. By contrast, a higher risk of bias was observed and was confined to specific items, the blinding of caregivers or investigators (D5) and blinding of outcome assessment (D7), where several studies exhibited insufficient safeguards. The detailed results of the SYRCLE risk-of-bias assessment are presented in Fig. 4.

SYRCLE risk-of-bias judgments
(low/unclear/high) across 10 domains (D1-D10) for all 64 studies.
The highest risk was confined to blinding domains (D5 and D7),
whereas outcome reporting (D8-D9) was consistently low risk.
SYRCLE, Systematic Review Centre for Laboratory animal
Experimentation. The domains are as follows: D1, sequence
generation; D2, baseline characteristics; D3, allocation
concealment; D4, random housing; D5, blinding of investigators; D6,
random outcome assessment; D7, blinding of outcome assessment; D8,
incomplete outcome data; D9, selective outcome reporting; D10,
other sources of bias.

Figure 4

SYRCLE risk-of-bias judgments (low/unclear/high) across 10 domains (D1-D10) for all 64 studies. The highest risk was confined to blinding domains (D5 and D7), whereas outcome reporting (D8-D9) was consistently low risk. SYRCLE, Systematic Review Centre for Laboratory animal Experimentation. The domains are as follows: D1, sequence generation; D2, baseline characteristics; D3, allocation concealment; D4, random housing; D5, blinding of investigators; D6, random outcome assessment; D7, blinding of outcome assessment; D8, incomplete outcome data; D9, selective outcome reporting; D10, other sources of bias.

Discussion

The present systematic review synthesized experimental rodent evidence on the molecular regulation of root dentinogenesis and organized the findings according to developmental phase and spatial region. Across the included studies, root formation emerged as a coordinated epithelial-mesenchymal process involving HERS, the apical progenitor compartment, odontoblast-lineage cells, and multiple interacting signaling pathways (1,3,5,31,51). The principal pattern identified was a transition from signaling associated with root initiation and progenitor maintenance toward pathways involved in odontoblast differentiation, dentin matrix deposition, mineralization and HERS remodeling (3,5,9,31,51).

Root initiation was associated with a transition at the cervical loop from the crown-forming program toward the root-forming program. The reviewed experimental evidence implicated the cessation of FGF10 signaling together with epithelial BMP/SMAD4 and SHH activity in this transition. BMP/SMAD4 signaling was linked to SHH induction, followed by mesenchymal NFIC activation and odontoblast-lineage specification (3,9). These findings support the interpretation that root initiation depends on coordinated signaling between the epithelium and adjacent mesenchyme rather than on an isolated molecular event (3,11).

During root elongation, the evidence supported a spatial organization of signaling along the apical-cervical axis. The apical region was associated with progenitor maintenance and proliferation involving SHH/Gli1, Wnt/β-catenin and FGF signaling (30,32,55), whereas the cervical-to-mid-root region exhibited greater involvement of BMP/TGF-β signaling and NFIC-dependent odontoblast differentiation (9,60,61,71). The disruption of these pathways was associated with region-specific phenotypes, including impaired proliferation, shortened roots, defective odontoblast differentiation and abnormal dentin formation (5,14-16,31,55). The detailed experimental evidence underlying these associations is presented in Tables I and SI.

Root maturation involved continued odontoblast differentiation, dentin matrix production, mineralization and the remodeling of HERS. Sustained NFIC activity and the expression of dentin-associated matrix genes, including DSPP and DMP1, were associated with functional dentin maturation (9,60,61). The evidence also indicated that HERS remodeling is an active developmental process. The appropriate regulation of epithelial β-catenin signaling is associated with controlled HERS dissociation and fragmentation into the epithelial rests of Malassez, whereas the disruption of β-catenin activity can lead to premature HERS disruption or the failure of HERS dissociation and abnormal root development (51).

The principal contribution of the present systematic review is the systematic organization of experimental rodent evidence across spatial and temporal dimensions. The present systematic review integrates predefined eligibility criteria with the structured extraction of developmental phase, spatial region, molecular perturbation, experimental technique, functional outcome and reported human correlation. This framework complements previous reviews of tooth-root development (72), while providing a structured synthesis focused specifically on experimentally investigated molecular mechanisms of root dentinogenesis. The aim was to identify reproducible associations and patterns across the available experimental evidence.

A key finding of this synthesis is that canonical Wnt/β-catenin signaling does not exert a uniformly promotive or inhibitory effect on root development. Its effects depend on the cellular compartment, developmental stage and interaction with other signaling pathways (4,12,31,47,51,55). Epithelial Wnt10a loss was associated with impaired HERS elongation and altered furcation patterning, whereas excessive β-catenin activity in odontoblast-lineage cells impaired root formation and was associated with abnormal differentiation and matrix formation (47). In HERS itself, β-catenin inactivation caused premature HERS disruption, whereas β-catenin stabilization prevented normal HERS dissociation (51). These opposing phenotypes indicate that both insufficient and excessive pathway activity can be detrimental. However, the available evidence does not establish a universal quantitative concentration threshold for Wnt activity, but the findings support the concept that an appropriate level of Wnt pathway activity is required within a specific cellular and developmental context.

The context dependence of Wnt signaling is further supported by pathway integration. The disruption of TGF-β signaling in root pre-odontoblasts increased Wnt activity and was associated with ectopic osteogenic differentiation and osteodentin formation (71), whereas RUNX2-dependent induction of the Wnt antagonist NOTUM provides a mechanism for restricting Wnt activity during odontoblast differentiation (29). Thus, Wnt signaling is better interpreted as one component of an interacting epithelial-mesenchymal regulatory network than as an independent linear pathway. The functional consequences of Wnt modulation therefore depend not only on the direction of pathway alteration, but also on where and when the alteration occurs.

The reviewed evidence similarly demonstrates that BMP signaling is context-dependent. Mesenchymal BMP4 can inhibit HERS elongation through BMP receptors expressed by HERS cells (19), whereas epithelial BMP2/4 signaling contributes to HERS development and subsequent root formation (23). TGF-β/BMP signaling also contributes to odontoblast maturation and dentin formation in a stage- and site-dependent manner (68). These apparently different effects emphasize the importance of cellular source and anatomical location when interpreting pathway function. They also illustrate why broad genetic manipulations may produce phenotypes that differ from those obtained when the same pathway is manipulated in a defined cellular compartment.

Taken together, the evidence supports a model of root dentinogenesis in which signaling pathways operate through coordinated spatial and temporal interactions, rather than as independent linear mechanisms. HERS, the apical progenitor compartment and differentiating odontoblasts participate in reciprocal signaling associations that are altered during root initiation, elongation and maturation (3,5,30,51). The systematic organization of these associations provides a framework for interpreting apparently divergent experimental findings and for identifying questions that require further mechanistic investigation.

From a translational perspective, the human evidence supports the biological conservation of selected molecular pathways; however, it does not establish direct equivalence between rodent and human root development. Human genetic findings and studies of human dental stem-cell systems support the relevance of selected pathways, while the complete spatial and temporal organization of these signals during human root development remains incompletely characterized (4,59,73). The findings should therefore be regarded as a conceptual framework for hypothesis generation and preclinical investigation rather than evidence of direct therapeutic efficacy.

The reviewed experimental models suggest that the successful modulation of root development may require appropriate spatial and temporal control of interacting pathways, rather than non-specific delivery of a single growth factor (30,51). However, methods capable of reproducing these developmental conditions in engineered tissues remain investigational. Preclinical rescue experiments provide proof-of-concept that selected molecular pathways can be experimentally modified, but they do not establish clinical efficacy, safety, or the feasibility of reproducing the complete developmental signaling environment (29,70).

Practical and clinical implications

From a clinical perspective, the findings suggest that numerous congenital and acquired root defects arise from the disruption of spatial signal coordination rather than from failure of odontogenesis. Developmental root malformations, such as short root anomaly and single-root agenesis are related to specific disorders in signaling pathway interactions between BMP, Wnt/β-catenin, SHH and the transcription regulators NFIC (4,23). Moreover, the shortened roots are associated with impaired apical growth of HERS due to the failure of coordination of epithelial-mesenchymal reciprocal interaction (73).

Furthermore, root defects associated with hypophosphatasia result from tissue-nonspecific alkaline phosphatase (TNAP) deficiency, which compromises the root dentin and cementum mineralization (70). In fact, the understanding that these phenotypes are failures in specific developmental modules, such as the apical progenitor niche or HERS degeneration aids in the early diagnosis and management of pediatric and orthodontic patients. Short and abnormal root development may predispose the individual to orthodontic complications and may require force modification during treatment (73,74).

For regenerative endodontic therapy, the evidence suggests that successful root regeneration requires recreating the spatially restricted signaling and targeting the apical apex. The collected data from the pre-clinical experimental rodent models indicate that the gradient of SHH, Wnt/β-catenin, BMP and other pathways control the proliferation and differentiation along the apical to cervical axis during root formation (5,53). Therefore, the non-specific growth factor delivery may not recapitulate the target developmental patterning.

Accordingly, targeting the SHH and Wnt dependent progenitor niche with simultaneously promoting BMP/TGF/β-catenin-NFIC promote the differentiation in cervical region are necessary to achieve functional root elongation and maturation (50,75). However, the specific approaches to spatially constrain these signals in engineered tissues remain investigational.

Another approach is enzyme replacement strategies, the supplementation of TNAP in case of hypophosphatasia models demonstrates correction of the pathway deficits and can rescue the root dentin mineralization, which provides a proof-of-concept for targeted molecular therapies. As previously demonstrated, in TNAP-null (Alpl-/-) mouse models, treatment with mineral-targeted TNAP prevented the dental hypo-mineralization and corrected defects of dentin and cementum formation (70), thereby supporting the concept that molecularly tailored therapy can restore critical aspects of root formation.

Implications for developmental and regenerative biology research

Theoretically, the present systematic review advances the understanding of tooth root development by framing it as a modular and gradient-driven process analogous to other organ elongation systems. Moreover, the morphogen gradients regulate not only root elongation, but also patterning and growth in diverse biological contexts, where the graded distributions of signaling molecules coordinate cell fate and proliferation during organogenesis (76). The identification of HERS as both a structural guide and a dynamic signaling center corresponds to the known role of epithelial organizers in other systems, such as the limb bud organizers as apical ectodermal ridge signaling and gut epithelial patterning (77,78). These organizers serve as sites of concentrated signaling activity that instruct and direct adjacent tissues with respect to spatial patterning and growth.

Furthermore, the integration of transcription factors, signaling pathways and the epigenetic regulators in root development suggest that root dentinogenesis is controlled by a multilayered regulatory network rather than a linear pathway. The developmental biology has established that epithelial-mesenchymal interactions and layered signaling modules, such as SHH, Wnt/β-catenin, BMP/TGF-β and downstream transcription factors are essential for coordinated morphogenesis across organs (77,79).

Notably, the repeated disruption of normal pathway activation across multiple genetic models supports the concept that regenerative success depends on restoring developmental patterning cues rather than simply inducing differentiation. In fact, signals such as SHH and BMP function as true morphogens with diffusible patterning cues that form gradients interpreted by cells to adopt distinct fates depending on concentration thresholds (76,80). Taken together, these principles indicate that tooth root regeneration research could benefit from gradient-based engineering models.

Several limitations should be considered when interpreting this synthesis. First, the majority of the included studies used mouse models, with only three studies using rats, which limits direct extrapolation to human root development. Second, substantial heterogeneity existed among studies in genetic models, developmental stages, experimental interventions, spatial regions, and outcome measures. Third, the incomplete reporting of randomization and blinding was common, contributing to uncertainty in some risk-of-bias domains. Finally, although the systematic synthesis identifies consistent spatial and temporal patterns, the available studies do not permit establishment of quantitative pathway thresholds or a definitive causal hierarchy among all signaling pathways. Accordingly, the proposed framework should be interpreted as an evidence-based synthesis of current experimental findings, rather than as a complete or definitive model of human root development.

In conclusion, the present systematic review supports a model in which root dentinogenesis is regulated by a spatially and temporally organized network of epithelial-mesenchymal interactions involving HERS, the apical progenitor compartment, odontoblast-lineage cells and multiple signaling pathways. The evidence indicates that FGF, SHH, Wnt/β-catenin, BMP/TGF-β, NFIC, RUNX2-NOTUM and dentin-matrix pathways contribute to distinct stages of root initiation, elongation and maturation. The context-dependent effects of Wnt/β-catenin emphasize the importance of cellular location, developmental timing, and pathway interaction. Human genetic and cellular findings support conservation of selected molecular mechanisms; however, the complete spatial and temporal framework identified in rodent models remains insufficiently characterized in humans. The present synthesis therefore provides an evidence-based conceptual framework for future developmental and preclinical studies of root formation and regeneration.

Supplementary Material

Detailed molecular signaling interactions and functional validation.
Rodent findings, human evidence and regenerative implications.

Acknowledgements

Not applicable.

Funding

Funding: No funding was received.

Availability of data and materials

The data generated in the present study may be requested from the corresponding author.

Authors' contributions

MHA conceptualized the study, was involved in the study methodology and provided software (Rayyan for screening; Microsoft Excel for data extraction/management). BA and MHA were involved in data curation, and in the writing and preparation of the original draft of the manuscript. MMFAH was involved in visualization (including figures and graphical presentation of the findings) and in the screening/investigation of included studies, the extraction of relevant evidence, and the assessment of study characteristics. BA supervised the study. MHA and MMFAH provided software (Rayyan for screening; Microsoft Excel for data extraction/management) and were involved in the validation of the extracted data and study findings. MHA was involved in the writing, reviewing and editing of the manuscript. MHA and BA confirm the authenticity of all the raw data. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

Not applicable.

Patient consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Use of artificial intelligence tools

During the preparation of this work, AI tools (ChatGPT and Paperpal) were used to improve the readability and language of the manuscript or to generate images, and subsequently, the authors revised and edited the content produced by the AI tools as necessary, taking full responsibility for the ultimate content of the present manuscript.

References

1 

Li J, Parada C and Chai Y: Cellular and molecular mechanisms of tooth root development. Development. 144:374–384. 2017.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

2 

Huang X, Bringas P Jr, Slavkin HC and Chai Y: Fate of HERS during tooth root development. Dev Biol. 334:22–30. 2009.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

3 

Huang X, Xu X, Bringas P Jr, Hung YP and Chai Y: Smad4-Shh-Nfic signaling cascade-mediated epithelial-mesenchymal interaction is crucial in regulating tooth root development. J Bone Miner Res. 25:1167–1178. 2010.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

4 

Yu M, Liu Y, Wang Y, Wong SW, Wu J, Liu H, Feng H and Han D: Epithelial Wnt10a is essential for tooth root furcation morphogenesis. J Dent Res. 99:311–319. 2020.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

5 

Liu Y, Feng J, Li J, Zhao H, Ho TV and Chai Y: An Nfic-hedgehog signaling cascade regulates tooth root development. Development. 142:3374–3382. 2015.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

6 

Lin Y, Yang F, Shang B, Speich JE, Wan YY, Hashida H, Braun T, Sadoughi A, Puehler T, Lue TF and Zhang K: Reporting quality of animal research in journals that published the ARRIVE 1.0 or ARRIVE 2.0 guidelines: A cross-sectional analysis of 943 studies. Cardiovasc Diagn Ther. 14:1070–1082. 2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

7 

García-González M, Munoz F, González-Cantalapiedra A, López-Pena M and Saulacic N: Systematic review and quality evaluation using ARRIVE 2.0 guidelines on animal models used for periosteal distraction osteogenesis. Animals (Basel). 11(1233)2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

8 

Hooijmans CR, Rovers MM, De Vries RB, Leenaars M, Ritskes-Hoitinga M and Langendam MW: SYRCLE's risk of bias tool for animal studies. BMC Med Res Methodol. 14(43)2014.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

9 

Steele-Perkins G, Butz KG, Lyons GE, Zeichner-David M, Kim HJ, Cho MI and Gronostajski RM: Essential role for NFI-C/CTF transcription-replication factor in tooth root development. Mol Cell Biol. 23:1075–1084. 2003.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

10 

Shimamura K, Nojiri T, Kondo H, Ikeda Y, Yasuhara R, Ida-Yonemochi H, Otsu K, Harada H, Mishima K, Ohshima H, et al: The potential role of chromodomain helicase DNA-binding protein 3 in defining the cervical width by regulating the early growth stage of the apical papilla during tooth development. J Oral Biosci. 67(100604)2025.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

11 

Yokohama-Tamaki T, Ohshima H, Fujiwara N, Takada Y, Ichimori Y, Wakisaka S, Ohuchi H and Harada H: Cessation of Fgf10 signaling, resulting in a defective dental epithelial stem cell compartment, leads to the transition from crown to root formation. Development. 133:1359–1366. 2006.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

12 

Sun K, Yu M, Wang J, Zhao H, Liu H, Feng H, Liu Y and Han D: A Wnt10a-Notch signaling axis controls Hertwig's epithelial root sheath cell behaviors during root furcation patterning. Int J Oral Sci. 16(25)2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

13 

Fujiwara N, Akimoto T, Otsu K, Kagiya T, Ishizeki K and Harada H: Reduction of Egf signaling decides transition from crown to root in the development of mouse molars. J Exp Zool B Mol Dev Evol. 312B:486–494. 2009.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

14 

Ma Y, Jing J, Feng J, Yuan Y, Wen Q, Han X, He J, Chen S, Ho TV and Chai Y: Ror2-mediated non-canonical Wnt signaling regulates Cdc42 and cell proliferation during tooth root development. Development. 148(dev196360)2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

15 

Pei F, Guo T, Zhang M, Ma L, Jing J, Feng J, Ho TV, Wen Q and Chai Y: FGF signaling modulates mechanotransduction/WNT signaling in progenitors during tooth root development. Bone Res. 12(37)2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

16 

Zheng X, Huang H, Zhou Z, Guo W, Yang G, Chen Z, Chen D, Chen Y and Yuan G: Axin1 regulates tooth root development by inhibiting AKT1-mTORC1 activation and Shh translation in Hertwig's epithelial root sheath. Development. 151(dev202899)2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

17 

Hirose N, Shimazu A, Watanabe M, Tanimoto K, Koyota S, Sugiyama T, Uchida T and Tanne K: Ameloblastin in Hertwig's epithelial root sheath regulates tooth root formation and development. PLoS One. 8(e54449)2013.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

18 

Ihn HJ, Kim JA, Lim J, Nam SH, Hwang SH, Kim YK, Kim JY, Kim JE, Cho ES, Jiang R and Park EK: Bobby sox homolog regulates tooth root formation through modulation of dentin sialophosphoprotein. J Cell Physiol. 236:480–488. 2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

19 

Hosoya A, Kim JY, Cho SW and Jung HS: BMP4 signaling regulates formation of Hertwig's epithelial root sheath during tooth root development. Cell Tissue Res. 333:503–509. 2008.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

20 

Huang X, Wang F, Zhao C, Yang S, Cheng Q, Tang Y, Zhang F, Zhang Y, Luo W, Wang C, et al: Dentinogenesis and tooth-alveolar bone complex defects in BMP9/GDF2 knockout mice. Stem Cells Dev. 28:683–694. 2019.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

21 

Gama A, Vargas-Franco JW, Sánchez Mesa DC, Restrepo Bedoya E, Amiaud J, Babajko S, Berdal A, Acevedo AC, Heymann D, Lézot F and Castaneda B: Origins of alterations to Rankl null mutant mouse dental root development. Int J Mol Sci. 21(2201)2020.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

22 

Nagata M, Gadhvi GT, Komori T, Arai Y, Manabe H, Chu AKY, Kaur R, Ali M, Yang Y, Tsutsumi-Arai C, et al: Wnt-directed CXCL12-expressing apical papilla progenitor cells drive tooth root formation. Nat Commun. 16(5510)2025.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

23 

Mu H, Liu X, Geng S, Su D, Chang H, Li L, Jin H, Wang X, Li Y, Zhang B and Xie X: Epithelial bone morphogenic protein 2 and 4 are indispensable for tooth development. Front Physiol. 12(660644)2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

24 

Liu L, Yao L, Lu Z, Jiang L, Zhang X, Liu X, Zhang W, Luan X, Zhang S, Xu W, et al: Epithelial-specific deletion of FAM20A leads to short root defects. Gene. 884(147731)2023.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

25 

Bae CH, Kim TH, Chu JY and Cho ES: New population of odontoblasts responsible for tooth root formation. Gene Expr Patterns. 13:197–202. 2013.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

26 

Kim TH, Bae CH, Yang S, Park JC and Cho ES: Nfic regulates tooth root patterning and growth. Anat Cell Biol. 48:188–194. 2015.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

27 

Fons Romero JM, Star H, Lav R, Watkins S, Harrison M, Hovorakova M, Headon D and Tucker AS: The impact of the eda pathway on tooth root development. J Dent Res. 96:1290–1297. 2017.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

28 

Chen X, Chen G, Feng L, Jiang Z, Guo W, Yu M and Tian W: Expression of Nfic during root formation in first mandibular molar of rat. J Mol Histol. 45:619–626. 2014.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

29 

Wen Q, Jing J, Han X, Feng J, Yuan Y, Ma Y, Chen S, Ho TV and Chai Y: Runx2 regulates mouse tooth root development via activation of WNT inhibitor NOTUM. J Bone Miner Res. 35:2252–2264. 2020.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

30 

Lav R, Krivanek J, Anthwal N and Tucker AS: Wnt signaling from Gli1-expressing apical stem/progenitor cells is essential for the coordination of tooth root development. Stem Cell Reports. 18:1015–1029. 2023.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

31 

Kim TH, Bae CH, Lee JC, Ko SO, Yang X, Jiang R and Cho ES: β-catenin is Required in Odontoblasts for Tooth Root Formation. J Dent Res. 92:215–221. 2013.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

32 

Lohi M, Tucker AS and Sharpe PT: Expression of Axin2 indicates a role for canonical Wnt signaling in development of the crown and root during pre- and postnatal tooth development. Dev Dyn. 239:160–167. 2010.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

33 

Liu C, Yuan H, Huang J, Ran S, Wei X, Yan X, Xue L, He TC, Zhang Y, Gu M, et al: Bmp9 modulates cell proliferation and intercellular junctions in HERS during tooth root development. Genes Dis. 13(101777)2025.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

34 

Li L, Liu P, Lv X, Yu T, Jin X, Wang R, Xie X, Wang Q, Liu Y and Saiyin W: Ablation of FAM20C caused short root defects via suppressing the BMP signaling pathway in mice. J Orofac Orthop. 84:349–361. 2023.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

35 

Xu H, Snider TN, Wimer HF, Yamada SS, Yang T, Holmbeck K and Foster BL: Multiple essential MT1-MMP functions in tooth root formation, dentinogenesis, and tooth eruption. Matrix Biol. 52-54:266–283. 2016.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

36 

Du J, Jing J, Yuan Y, Feng J, Han X, Chen S, Li X, Peng W, Xu J, Ho TV, et al: Arid1a-Plagl1-Hh signaling is indispensable for differentiation-associated cell cycle arrest of tooth root progenitors. Cell Rep. 35(108964)2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

37 

Park JC, Herr Y, Kim HJ, Gronostajski RM and Cho MI: Nfic gene disruption inhibits differentiation of odontoblasts responsible for root formation and results in formation of short and abnormal roots in mice. J Periodontol. 78:1795–1802. 2007.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

38 

Ono W, Sakagami N, Nishimori S, Ono N and Kronenberg HM: Parathyroid hormone receptor signalling in osterix-expressing mesenchymal progenitors is essential for tooth root formation. Nat Commun. 7(11277)2016.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

39 

Yun CY, Choi H, You YJ, Yang JY, Baek JA and Cho ES: Requirement of Smad4-mediated signaling in odontoblast differentiation and dentin matrix formation. Anat Cell Biol. 49:199–205. 2016.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

40 

Zhang R, Yang G, Wu X, Xie J, Yang X and Li T: Disruption of Wnt/β-catenin signaling in odontoblasts and cementoblasts arrests tooth root development in postnatal mouse teeth. Int J Biol Sci. 9:228–236. 2013.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

41 

Lapthanasupkul P, Feng J, Mantesso A, Takada-Horisawa Y, Vidal M, Koseki H, Wang L, An Z, Miletich I and Sharpe PT: Ring1a/b polycomb proteins regulate the mesenchymal stem cell niche in continuously growing incisors. Dev Biol. 367:140–153. 2012.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

42 

Huang H, Wang J, Zhang Y, Zhu G, Li YP, Ping J and Chen W: Bone resorption deficiency affects tooth root development in RANKL mutant mice due to attenuated IGF-1 signaling in radicular odontoblasts. Bone. 114:161–171. 2018.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

43 

Wang J, McVicar A, Chen Y, Deng HW, Zhao Z, Chen W and Li YP: Atp6i deficient mouse model uncovers transforming growth factor-β1/Smad2/3 as a key signaling pathway regulating odontoblast differentiation and tooth root formation. Int J Oral Sci. 15(35)2023.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

44 

Cui Y, Li C, Wang H, Li L, Xie J, Zhou X, Zhang H and Sun J: Hemicentin-1 is an essential extracellular matrix component during tooth root formation by promoting mesenchymal cells differentiation. Front Cell Dev Biol. 12(1435241)2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

45 

Zhang R, Teng Y, Zhu L, Lin J, Yang X, Yang G and Li T: Odontoblast β-catenin signaling regulates fenestration of mouse Hertwig's epithelial root sheath. Sci China Life Sci. 58:876–881. 2015.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

46 

Sheng R, Wang Y, Wu Y, Wang J, Zhang S, Li Q, Zhang D, Qi X, Xiao Q, Jiang S and Yuan Q: METTL3-Mediated m6A mRNA methylation modulates tooth root formation by affecting NFIC translation. J Bone Miner Res. 36:412–423. 2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

47 

Bae CH, Lee JY, Kim TH, Baek JA, Lee JC, Yang X, Taketo MM, Jiang R and Cho ES: Excessive Wnt/β-catenin signaling disturbs tooth-root formation. J Periodontal Res. 48:405–410. 2013.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

48 

Lee TY, Lee DS, Kim HM, Ko JS, Gronostajski RM, Cho MI, Son HH and Park JC: Disruption of Nfic causes dissociation of odontoblasts by interfering with the formation of intercellular junctions and aberrant odontoblast differentiation. J Histochem Cytochem. 57:469–476. 2009.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

49 

Khan M, Seppala M, Zoupa M and Cobourne MT: Hedgehog pathway gene expression during early development of the molar tooth root in the mouse. Gene Expr Patterns. 7:239–243. 2007.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

50 

Nakatomi M, Morita I, Eto K and Ota MS: sonic hedgehog signaling is important in tooth root development. J Dent Res. 85:427–431. 2006.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

51 

Yang S, Choi H, Kim TH, Jeong JK, Liu Y, Harada H and Cho ES: Cell dynamics in Hertwig's epithelial root sheath are regulated by β-catenin activity during tooth root development. J Cell Physiol. 236:5387–5398. 2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

52 

Hosoya A, Takebe H, Seki-Kishimoto Y, Noguchi Y, Ninomiya T, Yukita A, Yoshiba N, Washio A, Iijima M, Morotomi T, et al: Polycomb protein Bmi1 promotes odontoblast differentiation by accelerating Wnt and BMP signaling pathways. Histochem Cell Biol. 163(11)2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

53 

Wang J, Ran S, Liu B and Gu S: Monitoring of canonical BMP and Wnt activities during postnatal stages of mouse first molar root formation. J Appl Oral Sci. 29(e20210281)2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

54 

Rakian A, Yang WC, Gluhak-Heinrich J, Cui Y, Harris MA, Villarreal D, Feng JQ, Macdougall M and Harris SE: Bone morphogenetic protein-2 gene controls tooth root development in coordination with formation of the periodontium. Int J Oral Sci. 5:75–84. 2013.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

55 

Bae CH, Kim TH, Ko SO, Lee JC, Yang X and Cho ES: Wntless regulates dentin apposition and root elongation in the mandibular molar. J Dent Res. 94:439–445. 2015.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

56 

Li G, Liu M, Zhang S, Wan H, Zhang Q, Yue R, Yan X, Wang X, Wang Z and Sun Y: Essential role of IFT140 in promoting dentinogenesis. J Dent Res. 97:423–431. 2018.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

57 

Sun W, Sun W, Liu J, Zhou X, Xiao Y, Karaplis A, Pollak MR, Brown E, Goltzman D and Miao D: Alterations in phosphorus, calcium and PTHrP contribute to defects in dental and dental alveolar bone formation in calcium-sensing receptor-deficient mice. Development. 137:985–992. 2010.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

58 

Nakatomi M, Ida-Yonemochi H and Ohshima H: Lymphoid enhancer-binding factor 1 expression precedes dentin sialophosphoprotein expression during rat odontoblast differentiation and regeneration. J Endod. 39:612–618. 2013.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

59 

Gao S, Zhao YM and Ge LH: Nuclear factor I-C expression pattern in developing teeth and its important role in odontogenic differentiation of human molar stem cells from the apical papilla. Eur J Oral Sci. 122:382–390. 2014.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

60 

Zhang H, Jiang Y, Qin C, Liu Y, Ho SP and Feng JQ: Essential role of osterix for tooth root but not crown dentin formation. J Bone Miner Res. 30:742–746. 2015.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

61 

Kim TH, Bae CH, Lee JC, Kim JE, Yang X, de Crombrugghe B and Cho ES: Osterix regulates tooth root formation in a site-specific manner. J Dent Res. 94:430–438. 2015.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

62 

Wang J, Muir AM, Ren Y, Massoudi D, Greenspan DS and Feng JQ: Essential roles of bone morphogenetic protein-1 and mammalian tolloid-like 1 in postnatal root dentin formation. J Endod. 43:109–115. 2017.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

63 

Foster BL, Nagatomo KJ, Tso HW, Tran AB, Nociti FH Jr, Narisawa S, Yadav MC, McKee MD, Millán JI and Somerman MJ: Tooth root dentin mineralization defects in a mouse model of hypophosphatasia. J Bone Miner Res. 28:271–282. 2013.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

64 

Lin X, Li Q, Hu L, Jiang C, Wang S and Wu X: Apical papilla regulates dental follicle fate via the OGN-Hh pathway. J Dent Res. 102:431–439. 2023.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

65 

Foster BL, Ao M, Salmon CR, Chavez MB, Kolli TN, Tran AB, Chu EY, Kantovitz KR, Yadav M and Narisawa S: , et al: Osteopontin regulates dentin and alveolar bone development and mineralization. Bone. 107:196–207. 2018.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

66 

Jeong JK, Kim TH, Choi H and Cho ES: Impaired breakdown of Herwig's epithelial root sheath disturbs tooth root development. Dev Dyn. 253:423–434. 2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

67 

Niibe K, Begun DL, Doi-Fujimura K, Nagasaki A, Zars E, Li X, Taylor EL, MacDougall MB, Egusa H and Westendorf JJ: Inhibition of histone deacetylase 3 in dental mesenchyme regulates the development of tooth root. J Bone Miner Res. 40:1177–1187. 2025.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

68 

Kim TH, Bae CH, Lee JY, Lee JC, Ko SO, Chai Y and Cho ES: Temporo-spatial requirement of Smad4 in dentin formation. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 459:706–712. 2015.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

69 

Zhang Y, Yuan L, Meng L, Fang M, Guo S, Wang D, Ma J and Wang L: Guanine and nucleotide binding protein 3 promotes odonto/osteogenic differentiation of apical papilla stem cells via JNK and ERK signaling pathways. Int J Mol Med. 43:382–392. 2019.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

70 

McKee MD, Nakano Y, Masica DL, Gray JJ, Lemire I, Heft R, Whyte MP, Crine P and Millán JL: Enzyme replacement therapy prevents dental defects in a model of hypophosphatasia. J Dent Res. 90:470–476. 2011.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

71 

Zhang R, Lin J, Liu Y, Yang S, He Q, Zhu L, Yang X and Yang G: Transforming growth factor-β signaling regulates tooth root dentinogenesis by cooperation with Wnt signaling. Front Cell Dev Biol. 9(687099)2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

72 

Rao P, Jing J, Fan Y and Zhou C: Spatiotemporal cellular dynamics and molecular regulation of tooth root ontogeny. Int J Oral Sci. 15(50)2023.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

73 

Luder HU: Malformations of the tooth root in humans. Front Physiol. 6(307)2015.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

74 

Vishwanath M, Chen PJ, Upadhyay M and Yadav S: Orthodontic management of a patient with short root anomaly and impacted teeth. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 155:421–431. 2019.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

75 

Huang XF and Chai Y: TGF-β signalling and tooth development. Chin J Dent Res. 13:7–15. 2010.PubMed/NCBI

76 

Schwank G and Basler K: Regulation of organ growth by morphogen gradients. Cold Spring Harb Perspect Biol. 2(a001669)2010.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

77 

de Santa Barbara P, Van Den Brink GR and Roberts DJ: Development and differentiation of the intestinal epithelium. Cell Mol Life Sci. 60:1322–1332. 2003.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

78 

Towers M, Wolpert L and Tickle C: Gradients of signalling in the developing limb. Curr Opin Cell Biol. 24:181–187. 2012.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

79 

Morali O, Savagner P and Larue L: Epithelium-mesenchyme transitions are crucial morphogenetic events occurring during early development. In: Madame Curie Bioscience Database. Landes Bioscience, Austin, TX, 2013.

80 

Mosby LS, Bowen AE and Hadjivasiliou Z: Morphogens in the evolution of size, shape and patterning. Development. 151(dev202412)2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

Related Articles

  • Abstract
  • View
  • Download
Copy and paste a formatted citation
Spandidos Publications style
Alwan M, Abdulghani B and Farhan Al-Halbosiy M: Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review. World Acad Sci J 8: 94, 2026.
APA
Alwan, M., Abdulghani, B., & Farhan Al-Halbosiy, M. (2026). Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review. World Academy of Sciences Journal, 8, 94. https://doi.org/10.3892/wasj.2026.509
MLA
Alwan, M., Abdulghani, B., Farhan Al-Halbosiy, M."Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review". World Academy of Sciences Journal 8.6 (2026): 94.
Chicago
Alwan, M., Abdulghani, B., Farhan Al-Halbosiy, M."Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review". World Academy of Sciences Journal 8, no. 6 (2026): 94. https://doi.org/10.3892/wasj.2026.509
Copy and paste a formatted citation
x
Spandidos Publications style
Alwan M, Abdulghani B and Farhan Al-Halbosiy M: Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review. World Acad Sci J 8: 94, 2026.
APA
Alwan, M., Abdulghani, B., & Farhan Al-Halbosiy, M. (2026). Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review. World Academy of Sciences Journal, 8, 94. https://doi.org/10.3892/wasj.2026.509
MLA
Alwan, M., Abdulghani, B., Farhan Al-Halbosiy, M."Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review". World Academy of Sciences Journal 8.6 (2026): 94.
Chicago
Alwan, M., Abdulghani, B., Farhan Al-Halbosiy, M."Molecular atlas of root dentinogenesis and spatiotemporal signaling pathways: A systematic review". World Academy of Sciences Journal 8, no. 6 (2026): 94. https://doi.org/10.3892/wasj.2026.509
Follow us
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
About
  • Spandidos Publications
  • Careers
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
How can we help?
  • Help
  • Live Chat
  • Contact
  • Email to our Support Team