Introduction
Breast cancer is the most common invasive cancer in females and the data indicate that this cancer led to 458,503 deaths worldwide in 2008 (1). As a number of studies are ongoing for identifying therapeutic strategies to combat this form of cancer, the progress is slow owing to its complexity. The resistance of breast cancer stem cells to conventional therapies such as chemotherapy (2) increases this complexity, as these cells are responsible for recurrence and disease progression. It has been reported that, even at the early stages of the disease, a portion of breast cancer cells may migrate to the bone marrow, and their entry into the bone marrow is facilitated by mesenchymal stem cells (3). These migrated cancer cells remain dormant, becoming active later thereby causing recurrence or advancement of the disease. CD3−CD56+ or CD16+ natural killer (NK) cells that possess the ability to identify and kill target cancer cells (4), particularly cancer stem cells (5,6) without prior sensitization makes them an important player in immunosurveillance and cancer defense in vivo. Therefore, NK cell-based immunotherapy may be a promising therapeutic strategy against cancer (4). There have been several studies investigating the role of NK cells in anticancer immunity and the outcome of cell-based immunotherapy in various types of solid cancer (4,7–9). In breast cancer, there have been reports on positive outcomes following cell-based immunotherapy (10,11). Chemotherapy has been reported to cause a decline in NK cell number and function (12), which may compromise their use in immunotherapy. In this context, the current study reports on the use of NK cell-based autologous immune enhancement therapy (AIET) in a patient with stage IIIA breast cancer, in whom a positive outcome was observed after adding AIET to conventional treatments. The observations concerning the decrease in the NK cell in vitro growth expansion with subsequent chemotherapy cycles in the patient are also reported.
Discussion
In a study that examined the prognosis of inflammatory breast cancer (IBC) by screening nearly 3,650 patients with breast cancer, the median progression-free survival period was 17 months. This study was from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), a large tertiary care center in India (18) and this may be considered as representative of Indian data on IBC, which is relevant to the present case, as the patient described is of Indian ethnicity. The patients in the AIIMS study underwent conventional therapies such as chemotherapy, modified radical mastectomy, radiotherapy and hormonal therapy as indicated. The patient described in the present case is having a disease-free survival period of >28 months following a combination therapy of chemotherapy, radiotherapy and surgery along with AIET, and is continuously under follow-up. The longer disease-free survival period may be attributable to the combination of AIET with the conventional therapies, which requires further validation in larger number of patients.
The complex nature of breast cancer biology, due to its genetic and hormonal influence, is further complicated by the migration of its cells to bone marrow even at an early stage (3), which leads to later recurrence of the disease. More complex is IBC, which has a very aggressive presentation, with the majority of patients ultimately succumbing to the disease. The present study examined in vitro NK cell expansion during administration of cell-based AIET concurrently with chemotherapy and surgery in a patient with stage IIIA IBC. The observation from the data is that, in this patient, the in vitro expansion of NK cells from PB withdrawn prior to the start of the chemotherapy cycles is higher (I–III transfusions), whereas with progressive chemotherapy, the quantity of NK cells following in vitro expansion decreased. In particular, after the surgery and the fourth cycle of chemotherapy, the expansion of NK cells decreased markedly (Fig. 2B). There are mixed reports in the literature on the effects of chemotherapy on NK cells. Although certain reports suggest that chemotherapy reduces the count and cytotoxicity of NK cells (12,19), another suggested an increase in NK cell cytotoxicity following chemotherapy (20). The present case report suggests that there is decrease in the in vitro expansion of NK cells with subsequent chemotherapy cycles. Although earlier studies have discussed the effects of chemotherapy on either the count or the in vitro cytotoxicity of the NK cells (12,19,20), to the best of our knowledge the current report is the first to provide details on the in vitro expansion potential of the NK cells, which has clinical significance as these expanded cells were used for immunotherapy in the patient described herein. Tai et al (21) reported that surgical stress induces dysfunction of NK cells, impairing their cytotoxic ability, thereby promoting tumor metastasis. The present report is in line with the Tai et al study, in which, following surgery, there was a significant decrease in the quantity of NK cells after in vitro expansion. Their cytotoxicity may also have been affected, which requires further study. The present report is of interest not only for the development of more focused therapies, but also for developing targeted therapies that will not compromise the cells of the immune system, as high densities of cytotoxic immune cells have been correlated with good prognosis in cancer (22–24), and proper functioning of immune cells such as NK cells is necessary to prevent metastasis (21). However, despite reduced NK cell quantities after in vitro expansion, the patient in the present case has remained disease-free for >28 months, which suggests that AIET, even with compromised NK cell function, may be able to contribute to a favorable prognosis. This may be due to the effects of the infused NK cells on encountered cancer cell targets, including circulating tumor cells, as NK cells have been observed to lyse circulating tumour emboli efficiently (25). Starting NK cell-based AIET immediately after diagnosis, as in the present case, may be advantageous, as these NK cells may also act on breast cancer cells that migrate to the bone marrow during the early stages of the disease, as well as targeting treatment-resistant breast cancer stem cells (3,5,6). Therefore, an assessment of NK cell expansion potential and cytotoxicity following conventional therapies in several patients may elucidate the potential loopholes of the immune system through which cancer is able to evade these immune cells, leading to disease recurrence and resistance to treatment. Further studies focusing on improving or modifying current therapeutic strategies for cancer so that they do not compromise the application of autologous immune cells must be performed, after which the approach of combining AIET with conventional therapies may be suggested for similar cases with proper validation.
In conclusion, combining NK cell-based AIET with surgery and chemotherapy was associated with >28 months of disease-free survival in a patient with stage IIIA IBC. The in vitro expansion potential of NK cells gradually declined with subsequent dosages of chemotherapy and markedly after surgery in this patient, which warrants an assessment of the immune system during therapies that compromise immunity to allow spread of cancer, and also to properly validate the timings of starting such immune-enhancing therapies. In addition, targeted cancer therapies that do not compromise the immune system are urgently required.