Basaloid squamous cell carcinoma of the maxillary gingiva: A case report and review of the literature

Introduction

Basaloid squamous cell carcinoma (BSCC) is an uncommon variant of squamous cell carcinoma (SCC), which was first described by Wain et al (1) in 1986. BSCC generally present in the upper aerodigestive tract, particularly in the larynx, hypopharynx and the base of the tongue (2). Ide et al (3) reported 46 cases of BSCC in the oral mucosa, where only one case occurred in the gingival tissues. In addition, Hirai et al (4) described two cases of BSCC in the mandibular gingiva. In the current study, an additional case of BSCC in the maxillary gingiva is presented and the clinical features of BSCC are reviewed according to the current literature. Patient provided written informed consent.

Case report

In October 2009, a 40-year-old male visited the outpatient clinic of Peking University, Shenzhen Hospital (Shenzhen, China) presenting with a painless irregular mass of the right maxillary gingiva as well as nasal obstruction following the presentation of the initial symptoms two months previously. The patient’s medical history was unremarkable. The patient had a history of smoking for a period of 15 years (frequency, 10/day), however, denied excessive alcohol consumption. The intraoral examination revealed a gray, irregular mass (size, 3×2.5×2 cm) in the right maxillary posterior buccal gingiva, which elicited marginal pain on palpation. An extraoral clinical examination identified various palpable, mobile lymph nodes in the right submandibular region, measuring ~1×1×1 cm that were firm and non-tender on palpation. A computed tomography (CT) scan demonstrated a tumor, which involved the right maxillary sinus and infiltrated the central region of the hard palate (Fig. 1). The chest CT was negative for distant metastatic lesions. The lesion was clinically and radiologically classified as cT4 cNx cM0, according to the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging manual (5). The treatment comprised of an extended surgical excision of the tumor, which involved a partial maxillectomy with mandibulectomy and ipsilateral functional neck dissection at levels I-III, where four enlarged lymph nodes were removed at level Ib.

Figure 1 Computed tomography images of the basaloid squamous cell carcinoma. (A and B) The mass invaded the maxillary sinus and the central region of the hard palate.

To investigate the excised tissue, the tissues were fixed in 10% buffered formalin and processed via the usual methods for paraffin embedding. The paraffin sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin. Immunohistochemical staining was performed using the BOND-MAX automated immunostainer (Vision BioSystems, Melbourne, Australia) to further define the diagnosis of the tumor. The antibodies that were used for immunohistochemistry are presented in Table I. The antigen retrieval method was heat-induced epitope retrieval in EDTA at an alkaline pH (pH 8.0). Adequate positive and negative tissue controls were used.

Table I Primary antibodies adopted for immunohistochemical staining.

Table I

Primary antibodies adopted for immunohistochemical staining.

Antibody	Clone	Source	Dilution	Result
p63	4A4	Santa Cruza	1:75	+
CK7	OV-TL12/30	Dakob	1:50	−
CK14	LL002	Novocastrac	1:50	−
CK-H	34βE12	Dakob	1:50	+
Vimentin	V9	Dakob	1:50	−
S-100	Antiserum	Dakob	1:4,000	−

a Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Inc. (Santa Cruz, CA, USA);

b Dako (Carpinteria, CA, USA);

c Novocastra Laboratories (Newcastle, UK).

{ label (or @symbol) needed for fn[@id='tfn4-ol-08-03-1287'] } CK, cytokeratin; CK-H, high molecular weight cytokeratin.

Microscopically, the tissues from the primary site demonstrated that there were two cellular populations; epithelial-like and basaloid tumor cells. The basaloid cells formed the primary invasive component of the cancer nests and were arranged in cords, trabeculae and lobules that occasionally demonstrated a pseudoglandular formation. These cells exhibited peripheral palisading and hyperchromatic nuclei with a high nucleus-cytoplasm ratio as well as a scant cytoplasm (Fig. 2A and B). Mitotic figures were observed within the nests and necrotic foci were scattered throughout the visual field. Components of SCC exhibiting keratinization were scarce, which differs to the features of conventional SCC. Immunohistochemically, the basaloid carcinoma cells were weakly positive for p63 (Fig. 2C) and focally positive for high molecular weight cytokeratin (CK-H; Fig. 2D), and negative for cytokeratin (CK)7, CK14, S-100 protein and vimentin. According to the clinical presentation, histopathological features and immunohistochemical findings, a final diagnosis of BSCC in the maxillary gingiva was determined. The surgical excision margins were healthy and the neck lymph node histopathology did not reveal any positive lymph nodes. The pathological staging of pT4 pN0 pM0 was established according to the AJCC staging manual.

Figure 2 (A) Histological sections of the basaloid squamous cell carcinoma (hematoxylin and eosin [H&E] stain; magnification, ×200) displayed central comedo-type necrosis in the cancer nest and (B) peripheral palisading with radially arranged cells at the periphery of the lobules. (C) Diffuse tumor cells were weakly positive for the p63 marker, and (D) intense high molecular weight cytokeratin-positivity was observed in the membrane and cytoplasm of the cancer cells (B–D: H&E stain; magnification, ×200).

However, the patient experienced recurrence half a year later and presented with a painful mass of the right cheek without enlarged lymph nodes on palpation. Following a failed tumor response to chemotherapy (dose, 16 mg pingyangmycin per day for seven days) and dimensional conformal radiotherapy (dose, 50 Gy), a second surgical intervention comprising of an extended resection of the neoplasm was conducted. Three years following treatment the patient remains free from tumor recurrence.

Discussion

BSCC is a rare and malignant tumor that presents in the head and neck region, including the oral mucosa, and has been defined as an aggressive and distinct variant of SCC, which is composed of basaloid and squamous components, according to the World health Organization (6). BSCC is particularly uncommon in the oral cavity and more so in the gingiva. According to Hirai et al (4), only eight cases of BSCC in the gingiva have been reported in the English literature (4,7–9), with only one case of BSCC occurring in the maxillary gingiva.

The clinical features of the BSCC cases that presented in the gingiva are reviewed and summarized in Table II. Two patients were female and seven were male with an age range of 40–79 years (mean age, 60.1 years). The most frequent site of origin was the mandible (n=7) followed by the maxilla (n=2). According to the standard tumor-node-metastasis (TNM) staging, provided by the AJCC, three patients presented in stage I, two in stage II, three in stage III, and one in stage IV. All of the patients were treated using surgery, four underwent neck dissections and three received adjuvant radiotherapy. Five patients had survived at the median follow-up time of 56 months.

Table II Reported cases of BSCC of the gingiva.

Table II

Reported cases of BSCC of the gingiva.

First author (ref)	Year	Age/gender	Stage	Location of lesion	Treatment	Final outcome	Follow-up period, months
Wedenberg et al (7)	1997	55/M	I	Maxilla	S	A	5
Abiko et al (8)	1998	79/F	I	Mandible	S	A	24
Yu et al (9)	2008	61/M	II	Mandible	S + FND	A	120
Yu et al (9)	2008	56/M	IV	Mandible	S	D	180
Yu et al (9)	2008	65/M	III	Mandible	S	D	2.5
Subramania et al (10)	2009	72/F	III	Mandible	S + FND + RT	A	12
Hirai et al (4)	2009	55/M	II	Mandible	S + FND	A	79
Hirai et al (4)	2009	65/M	I	Mandible	S + RT	A	60
Present case	2010	40/M	III	Maxilla	S + FND + RT	A	25

[i] S, surgery; FND, functional neck dissection; RT, radiotherapy; A, alive; D, died.

The prognosis of patients with BSCC compared with patients with conventional SCC remains uncertain. Winzenburg et al (10) first identified that distant metastases occurred in 52% of patients with BSCC and in 13% of patients with poorly differentiated SCC. Soriano et al (11) showed that patients with SCC were associated with notably higher survival rates when compared with patients with BSCC; furthermore, the rate of distant metastasis was six times higher in the cases of BSCC. However, de Sampaio Góes et al (12) declared that the prognosis did not differ between patients with BSCC of the oral cavity and those with conventional SCC.

The diagnosis of BSCC is currently based on histological criteria, including focal squamous differentiation, a basaloid pattern that is associated with frank invasive SCC or carcinoma in situ. However, the histopathological diagnosis of BSCC is difficult to differentiate from that of adenoid cystic carcinoma (ACC), poorly differentiated carcinoma and basal cell adenocarcinoma. BSCC may easily be misdiagnosed as ACC, particularly when a small biopsy sample is used.

Previous studies have advocated that immunohistochemical markers, including CK7, CK14, p63, CK-H, S-100 and vimentin aid with distinguishing BSCC from ACC (13,14). Colleta et al (13) reported that the majority of cancer cells of ACC express CK7, which indicates a ductal-pattern possibly of salivary gland origin, while in BSCC, the basaloid cells exhibit positive expression for CK17 and negative expression for vimentin, S-100, CK7, CK8 or CK20. The p63 staining pattern of BSCC and ACC is markedly different; the positive p63 staining is diffused in ~100% of the BSCC cancer cells, while ACC demonstrates a compartmentalized pattern within the tumor nests (15). In addition, the expression of CK-H is positive in BSCC cases (14). In the present case the immunohistochemical staining was positive for p63 and CK-H, and negative for S-100, vimentin, CK14 and CK7. Thariat et al (16) also advocated another criterion (in addition to the original criteria and immunohistochemical findings reported by Wain et al [1]) and proposed that, owing to its dual behavior that is marginally dependent on its association with the human papilloma virus (HPV), the BSCC patients should be systematically examined for their HPV status as this may determine the treatment response (17).

BSCC require aggressive multimodality treatment, including radical surgical excision, neck dissection, radiotherapy and regular chemotherapy due to the high overall mortality rate. Although chemotherapy is recommended by certain authors due to the high incidence of distant metastasis and the relatively poor prognosis (17), a standard chemotherapy regimen for BSCC has not yet been established. Furthermore, investigation of a greater number of patients is required to determine the efficacy of chemotherapy for BSCC of the head and neck. Bonner et al (18) advocated that immunotherapy elicited an improved treatment effect when compared with radiotherapy alone and resulted in a reduced mortality rate.

In conclusion, the aggressive behavior of BSCC has been presented using a rare case of the maxillary gingiva. The potential difficulties of a histological diagnosis were discussed and the possible obstacles to an accurate diagnosis were emphasized. Further studies with uniform reporting are required in order to optimize the establishment of a diagnosis and define the optimum treatment strategies.

Acknowledgements

The present study was supported by the Department of Cranio-Maxillofacial and Oral Surgery, University Hospital Zürich (Zürich, Switzerland). In addition, financial support was provided by the Guangdong Province Nature Science Foundation (grant no. S2012010010382) and the Shenzhen Science and Research Innovation Foundation (grant no. JCY20130402114702120).

Abbreviations:

References