COL2A1 mutation (c.3508G>A) leads to avascular necrosis of the femoral head in a Chinese family: A case report

Introduction

Numerous factors, including trauma, alcohol, steroids, coagulation disorders, sickle cell disease and fat embolism, have been reported to be implicated in the destruction of the femoral head (1). Avascular necrosis of the femoral head (ANFH), as a consequence of impaired blood supply, is a common type II collagenopathy that is associated with collagen type II α1 chain (COL2A1) mutations (2,3). The primary clinical manifestations of ANFH are limping gait, discrepancy in leg length and pain on exertion, which have a substantial effect on the quality of life of individuals (4,5). Although the exact pathogenesis of ANFH remains to be elucidated, evidence obtained from idiopathic osteonecrosis in twin studies indicates that genetic factors may have a vital role in the development of ANFH (6,7). Additionally, genetic studies have demonstrated that various single nucleotide mutations in COL2A1 are associated with an increased risk of ANFH. Based on the data obtained from familial ANFH patients in three Chinese families, a study conducted by Liu et al (2) revealed that a G to A transition in exon 50 (c.3665G>A) or exon 30 (c.2306G>A) in COL2A1 led to the replacement of glycine (Gly) with serine at codon 1,170 in the Gly-X-Y domain among patients with ANFH, which did not occur in healthy individuals. Furthermore, a study conducted by Li et al (8) revealed that a novel p.Gly630Ser mutation in the COL2A1 gene may have led to ANFH and Legg-Calve-Perthes disease (LCPD) in a Chinese family.

The COL2A1 gene, which is localized at 12q13, encodes the necessary element for type II collagen, characterized by three homologous α1-peptide chains (9). Type II collagen is predominantly expressed in the hyaline cartilage, as well as the vitreous body and nucleus pulposus (10). Type II collagen is also an essential component of collagen in the connective tissue; the biomechanical strength of this tissue is primarily dependent on the amount and extent of collagen fibril crosslinking (11). Type II collagen is composed of three homologous α1 peptide chains (homotrimers) that twist together to form a triple-stranded helix. The triple helical domain contains ~300 amino acids, and Gly followed by two other amino acids (AAs) constitute the repeated (Gly-X-Y)n sequence. If Gly in the specific Gly-X-Y repeat is replaced by other AAs, the structure of the type II collagen is destroyed (8,12). Over 200 mutations have been identified in the COL2A1 gene, and the majority of these mutations have been associated with the replacement of Gly residues in the triple helix domain (13). In recent decades, an increasing number of studies have indicated that mutations in the COL2A1 gene are associated with familial or inherited ANFH (8,14–20). However, at present, no mutation hotspot has been confirmed. The present study was performed to identify potential mutations in the COL2A1 gene that may be implicated in ANFH among a unique three-generation Chinese family, and to conduct a review of the literature.

Case report

Ethics statement

All experimental protocols described in the present study were approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Second Hospital of Yueyang (Yueyang, China). Written informed consent according to the Declaration of Helsinki was obtained from all subjects described in the present study.

Case presentation and pedigree analysis

A femoral head osteonecrosis pedigree with a total of 31 subjects (13 males and 18 females) of three generations (Yueyang, China) was recruited in the present study in July 2016. The proband (II-5), a male diagnosed with ANFH, visited the Second Hospital of Yueyang (Yueyang, China) in July 2014 due to groin pain and restricted motion of the left hip joint, which started when the patient was 41 years old. A comprehensive survey was conducted to obtain detailed information of the patient's medical history, physical examination and laboratory examination. Total hip replacement surgery was performed on his right hip joint in July 2014 in the Second Hospital of Yueyang. The radiograph revealed that the primary pathological change in his left hip was a flat femoral head with cystic degeneration, secondary osteoarthritis (OA) and light subluxation, indicating a Ficat stage IV lesion (21) (Fig. 1A). The patient was treated with total hip arthroplasty (Fig. 1B) and a post-operation biopsy confirmed the diagnosis.

Figure 1. Radiograph of the proband, subject II-5. (A) X-ray of the proband's left hip revealed cysts, joint space narrowing and secondary osteoarthritis. (B) Total hip replacement was performed on the proband as treatment. No abnormal signs were detected on the proband's (C) thoracic vertebra and (D) lumbar vertebra. L, left; R, right.

The X-ray of the patient's spine was normal (Fig. 1C and D) and facial features were unremarkable. There were no obvious abnormalities in the patient's neurological system or limbs. A total of 11 members of the proband's family (II-1, II-8, II-9, II-10, II-12 and III-6 to III-11) had similar clinical manifestations observed in X-rays (data not shown). Due to the aggregation of similar hip disorders in this family, a pedigree analysis was conducted to determine the potential cause (Fig. 2). Subjects of the first generation had passed away.

Figure 2. Pedigree analysis of the affected family. Subjects II-1, II-5, II-8, II-9, II-10, II-12 and III-6 to III-11 were diagnosed with avascular necrosis of the femoral head and a heterozygous c.3508G>A mutation in COL2A1 was detected in the above patients, excluding subject II-1. Subjects II-4 and III-5 were asymptomatic carriers. Subjects of the first generation had passed away. Squares represent males and circles represent females. Filled shapes represent affected family members, unfilled shapes represent unaffected family members and partially shaded shapes represent asymptomatic carriers of the c.3508G>A mutation in COL2A1. Shapes with a diagonal line through them indicate deceased family members. COL2A1, collagen type II α1 chain.

A total of 12 family members (54.5% of the offspring) were clinically diagnosed with ANFH (Fig. 2). Radiographic data revealed the typical features of the affected hips, including cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA and subluxation, indicating lesion stages ranging from Ficat II to IV. No family members had a history of trauma, alcohol, steroid use or any other high-risk factors.

Nucleic acid isolation

Blood samples of 22 family members from the same lineage as the proband and 20 sporadic ANFH volunteers were collected in July 2016 at the Second Hospital of Yueyang. Diagnois was conducted by an independent pathologist and imaging doctors. Characteristics of affected family members and sporadic ANFH volunteers are presented in Tables I and II, respectively. Genomic DNA was extracted from peripheral blood samples (200 µl) using the TIANamp Blood DNA kit (Tiangen Biotech Co., Ltd., Beijing, China), according to the manufacturer's protocol, and stored at −20°C prior to experimentation. The concentration and purity of the genomic DNA was measured using a NanoDrop 2000 spectrophotometer (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Inc., Waltham, MA, USA) at 260/280 nm. The process of blood sample collection and mutation detection was double-blinded. No authors had access to information that could identify individual participants during or following data collection.

Table I. Summary of findings of the affected members.

Table I.

Summary of findings of the affected members.

Family members	Age	Sex	Age at onset	Major symptoms	Radigraphic findings	Genotype	Affected hip
II 1	79	M	76	Groin pain/limping	Cystic/collapse/joint space narrowing/secondary OA	Nomal	Bilateral
II 4	75	F		Asymptomatic	Normal	Mutation
II 5	71	M	60	Groin pain/limping/restricted motion	Cystic/joint space narrowing/secondary OA	Mutation	Bilateral
II 8	68	F	20	Groin pain/limping	Cystic/joint space narrowing/secondary OA	Mutation	Bilateral
II 9	66	M	30	Groin pain/limping/restricted motion	Cystic/joint space narrowing/secondary OA	Mutation	Bilateral
II 10	64	M		Groin pain	Cystic	Mutation	Right
II 12	62	M	30	Groin pain/limping	Cystic/collapse/joint space narrowing	Mutation	Right
III 5	58	F		Asymptomatic	Normal	Mutation
III 6	50	M	49	Groin pain	Cystic	Mutation	Right
III 7	46	F	32	Groin pain/limping	Cystic/collapse/joint space narrowing	Mutation	Bilateral
III 8	45	M	30	Groin pain/limping	Cystic/joint space narrowing	Mutation	Bilateral
III 9	39	F	23	Groin pain/limping	Cystic/joint space narrowing	Mutation	Bilateral
III 10	48	F	38	Groin pain/limping	Cystic/joint space narrowing	Mutation	Bilateral
III 11	41	M	40	Groin pain	Normal	Mutation	Left

[i] F, female; OA, osteoarthritis; M, male.

Table II. Clinical data of 20 volunteer patients with sporadic avascular necrosis of the femoral head.

Table II.

Clinical data of 20 volunteer patients with sporadic avascular necrosis of the femoral head.

Sporadic members	Age	Sex	Age of onset	Major symptoms	Radiographic findings	Affected hip
1	57	F	42	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Right
2	64	F	63	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
3	67	M	66	Groin pain, limping, restricted motion	Cysts, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Right
4	51	M	47	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Right
5	66	M	64	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, joint space narrowing, collapse	Bilateral
6	85	M	79	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
7	77	M	67	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing	Left
8	59	M	55	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing	Left
9	62	M	52	Groin pain, limping, restricted motion	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
10	66	F	63	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, subluxation, joint space narrowing	Bilateral
11	63	F	60	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
12	64	M	62	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, joint space narrowing	Left
13	75	F	67	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, joint space narrowing	Right
14	47	M	46	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
15	64	M	62	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
16	67	F	62	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
17	67	F	61	Groin pain, limping, restricted motion	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
18	71	M	67	Groin pain, limping	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Left
19	64	M	63	Groin pain, limping, restricted motion	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Bilateral
20	68	M	62	Groin pain, limping, restricted motion	Cysts, collapse, joint space narrowing, secondary OA	Bilateral

[i] F, female; OA, osteoarthritis; M, male.

COL2A1 gene mutation analysis

Primers were designed based on the sequences of exon 50 in the COL2A1 gene, as previously described (9). The primer sequences were as follows: COL2A1-exon 50, TTTCCCAGCACTGATCATGG (forward) and GCCTCTCGCTGTCAGACAGA (reverse). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was performed using Pfu DNA Polymerase (Tiangen Biotech Co., Ltd.) in the T100 Thermal Cycler (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc., Hercules, CA, USA) with 100 ng genomic DNA as the template. The PCR was conducted with the following thermocycling conditions: 95°C for 5 min, followed by 35 cycles of 95°C for 30 sec, 60°C for 30 sec and 72°C for 60 sec, and final extension at 72°C for 5 min. The PCR products were subsequently sequenced by Sangon Biotech Co., Ltd (Shanghai, China). The sequencing results were compared to the National Center for Biotechnology Information reference sequence (NG_008072.1) (22) using DNAMAN 6.0 software (Lynnon LLC, San Ramon, CA, USA).

A heterozygous c.3508G>A mutation within exon 50 of the COL2A1 gene was identified in the proband (Fig. 3A) and other affected members in this family, excluding subject II-1. The repeated analysis obtained the same results. Genetic analysis revealed that this mutation was inherited in an autosomal dominant manner. No mutation was found at c.3508G>A in subject II-1, in which onset began at 76 years old. However, the patient received sequential bilateral total hip arthroplasty. Subjects II-2 and III-5 were also confirmed to be asymptomatic carriers and require future follow-up. The mutation described above was not detected in the other family subjects or the 20 sporadic ANFH patients (Fig. 3B).

Figure 3. Sequencing analysis of COL2A1. (A) A 3508C>T substitution was identified in the proband, as indicated by the arrow within the antisense strand of exon 50 in the COL2A1 gene, indicating a heterozygous c.3508G>A mutation. This mutation may result in the replacement of glycine by serine at codon 1,170 in COL2A1. This transition was also detected in other affected family members, excluding subject II-1. (B) The mutation was not detected in unaffected family members or the 20 sporadic patients. COL2A1, collagen type II α1 chain.

Histology

To observe the pathological alterations, cartilage with the most severe necrosis area in the margin of the femoral head from mutant (II-5 and II-9) and control (sporadic members) groups was collected. The cartilage specimens were fixed in 10% neutral-buffered formalin overnight at 4°C, dehydrated in an alcohol gradient, and embedded in low-melting point paraffin. Continuous 5-µm thick tissue sections were cut and fixed onto silicified slides using neutral resin size at room temperature. The sections were deparaffinised and rehydrated with deionized Millipore water (EMD Millipore, Billerica, MA, USA). Sections were stained with 1% toluidine blue with borate for 20 min at 20–25°C, rinsed with tap water, dehydrated, immersed in xylene for 10 min, and then mounted with neutral resins (17).

The presence of necrotic trabeculae or newly formed trabeculae, necrotic bone marrow and fibrous tissue was observed in inherited ANFH (Fig. 4A), subject II-1 without the COL2A1 c.3508G>A mutation (Fig. 4B) and sporadic ANFH (Fig. 4C). Furthermore, empty lacunae without osteocytes were observed in both Fig. 4B and C. No marked differences were observed between inherited and sporadic ANFH.

Figure 4. Histopathological analysis of femoral head cartilage by hematoxylin and eosin staining. Necrotic trabeculae (black arrows) or newly formed trabeculare (long white arrows), necrotic bone marrow and fibrous tissue (short white arrows) was observed in (A) inherited ANFH, (B) subject II-1 and (C) sporadic ANFH. Empty lacunae without osteocytes (black triangles) were observed in both subject II-1 and patients with sporadic ANFH. Subject II-1 was a family member with ANFH that did not possess the c.3508G>A mutation in collagen type II α1 chain that other affected family members had. No observable differences were identified between inherited and sporadic ANFH. ANFH, avascular necrosis of the femoral head. (Light microscope, magnification ×40).

Discussion

The present study identified a heterozygous c.3508G>A mutation in the COL2A1 gene, which resulted in inherited ANFH in a large Chinese family. Unexpectedly, one family member with ANFH (II-1) had a normal genotype compared with the other affected family members; further investigation into the identification of the possible mutated genes is required. In recent decades, >200 mutations have been identified in the COL2A1 gene, including single substitution, splice-site mutations and partial deletions (2,3,8). Type II collagen is a major component of the articular cartilage, which reduces articular friction and absorbs load pressure during movement. COL2A1 mutations have been associated with various human disorders, which are collectively termed type II collagenopathies and include spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia congenita, Kniest dysplasia, Stickler dysplasia, otospondylomegaepiphyseal dysplasia and spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia with premature onset arthrosis (23–26).

The c.3508G>A transition identified in the present study resulted in the replacement of Gly by serine at codon 1,170 in the affected family members, leading to a hip disorder that manifested as inherited ANFH. This did not occur in control family members. Liu et al (2) revealed that a c.3665G>A transition (p.G1170S) or c.2306G>A transition (p.G717S) in the COL2A1 gene led to ANFH in three Chinese families. However, the differing histopathology between inherited and sporadic ANFH and the histopathological characteristics of the mutant subjects has yet to be further discussed (2). All subjects with ANFH from the three families were confirmed to have different COL2A1 mutations. However, in the present study, no similar mutations were detected in one of the family members (subject II-1), which strongly indicates that acquired factors may have an irreversible role in the pathogenesis of ANFH. Additionally, it was reported that a c.4148G>A (18) or c.1774G>A mutations (19) in the COL2A1 gene may also lead to familial ANFH. Notably, evidence from clinical studies has demonstrated that a single base substitution in the COL2A1 gene is also implicated in the development of LCPD (8,14,25) and premature hip OA, which are two other types of type II collagenopathies (16,27). However, it remains to be determined whether these diseases occur separately or simultaneously in a single family with COL2A1 mutations. Although a c.3508G>A transition was not reported to be associated with idiopathic osteonecrosis of the femoral head (iONFH) in sporadic Japanese patients, studies have indicated that a c.3508G>A mutation may be the root cause of familial Ionfh (3). However, it remains unclear whether the G>A transition (p.G1170S) is the hotspot mutation in COL2A1 that leads to inherited hip disorders in Chinese individuals (3). Hence, this requires further investigation.

Type II collagen is predominantly expressed in the matrix and chondrocytes. The morphology and density of chondrocytes vary according to the different depths of normal articular cartilage surface, which is divided into three zones: Superficial zone (10–20%), middle zone (40–60%), and deep zone (30%) (11). One histological study revealed that the deep zone in inherited ANFH dramatically increased to 70%, from 30% in normal samples, and the superficial zone dramatically decreased to 10% (17). As mature chondrocytes are primarily distributed in the superficial zone, these results indicated that the number of mature chondrocytes is significantly decreased in inherited ANFH. Furthermore, although mutated type II collagen was reported to be secreted into the matrix, the non-uniform arrangement and distribution of the pathological collagen indicated that the biomechanical characteristics of the pathological cartilage was destroyed. As endochondral ossification occurs in infant development of the femoral head, the biomechanical properties of the subchondral bone may also be markedly weakened (27). These features are notably different from sporadic ANFH, which begins with subchondral bone necrosis and does not affect the articular cartilage (28–30). No marked differences between inherited and sporadic ANFH were demonstrated in the present study. This may due to the different biopsy locations or the small sample size.

The process of type II collagen synthesis and assembly has been reported to be impaired in chondrocytes with a COL2A1 mutation (31,32). The pro-α1 peptide chain encoded by COL2A1 forms a triple-helix structure within the endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi bodies of chondrocytes, which integrates into numerous fibrin networks following secretion from the extracellular matrix (10,11). The Gly-X-Y triple-helix motif is crucial for the proper crosslinking of the pro-α1 peptide chain to form functional type II collagen. The deletion of sequences for maintaining the Gly-X-Y triple-helix domain lead to type II collagenopathies (33,34). Mortier et al reported that there are numerous excessive post-translational modifications in type II collagen in individuals carrying a Gly-substituted mutation (35). These excessively modified type II collagens prevent the protein from folding into its fundamental triple-helical domain structure (35). In addition, an increase in hydroxymethyl may cause local structural damage and a loosened super helix structure, resulting in pathological alterations (8,11). However, why this mutation only appears to affect the hip joint remains unknown and suggests that other biomechanical factors may be involved, which require further investigation.

In conclusion, the present study identified a heterozygous c.3508G>A mutation in COL2A1 that was implicated in familial ANFH, and was compatible with autosomal dominant inheritance. The present study may provide a novel molecular basis for genetic counseling and the molecular diagnosis of ANFH. Further studies are required to investigate the potential mechanism underling COL2A1 mutation-induced inherited ANFH.

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Professor Xie Hui and Dr Chen Tuanhui from the Movement System Injury and Repair Research Center of Xiangya Hospital, Central South University (Changsha, China) for their methodological support with gene mutation analysis.

Funding

No funding was received.

Availability of data and materials

The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Authors' contributions

FL and ZX conceived and designed the study. QL, JH and WL performed the experiments. QL, JH and NZ provided the mutants. FL and ZX wrote the paper. ZX reviewed and edited the manuscript. All authors read and approved the manuscript.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

All experimental protocols described in the present study were approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Second Hospital of Yueyang (Yueyang, China). Written informed consent was obtained from all patients, or parent, guardian or next of kin described in the present study.

Consent for publication

All the experimental protocols described in this study were approved by The Ethics Committee of Hunan Normal University (Yueyang, China). Written informed consent was obtained from all patients, or parent, guardian or next of kin for the publication of any associated data and accompanying images.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

References